00:00:00.000Hello, and welcome to Vulgar History, a feminist women's history comedy podcast. My name is
00:00:17.260Anne Foster, and this is part of our season about Mary, Queen of Scots. There's something
00:00:21.900about Mary, Queen of Scots. So one of the reference books that I refer to, I think in
00:00:27.720And so far, every episode that I've done so far about Mary Queen of Scots has been this book, Daughters of the North, Jean Gordon and Mary Queen of Scots by Jennifer Morag Henderson.
00:00:38.860So it's a dual biography of Mary Queen of Scots, as well as Jean Gordon, who's a woman we talked about just this past week in the episode where we were talking about Bothwell.
00:00:48.440She was daughter of Cock O'The North, George Gordon, and then Mary Queen of Scots arranged
00:00:54.000her marriage to Bothwell, and then Bothwell ended that marriage when he did what he did
00:00:58.680in the last episode we were just talking about. But Jean herself is such an interesting person.
00:01:04.540And so I invited Jennifer Morag Henderson, the author of this book, to come on and talk about
00:01:09.140Jean because nobody can speak more authoritatively about her other than her biographer. But also,
00:01:15.180I do want to say that it was really exciting to talk to Jennifer because her book is like the
00:01:19.860Mary Queen of Scots parts, but also her description of the whole Cock o'er the North scenario,
00:01:25.340the way that she explains the Highlands and kind of what some of Mary Queen of Scots decision
00:01:29.340making, even when it gets into Bothwell, was really, really helpful for me in developing
00:01:34.060the episodes that I've done about Mary Queen of Scots. Because Jennifer is coming to this from,
00:01:39.540which was, it's a different viewpoint than what some other biographies are coming
00:01:43.300at it with. And it really resonated with me kind of looking at Mary as a political figure,
00:01:48.540how she's making her decisions. Anyway, it's a really great book. So I recommend the book
00:01:53.680for sure, Daughters of the North, Jean Gordon, Mary, Queen of Scots by Jennifer Morick Henderson.
00:01:58.860And today we're going to be talking about Jean Gordon. And I'm posting this episode today because
00:02:03.140that Bothwell episode was rough. That was, I didn't want to leave you for a week just with,
00:02:08.980you know, that bad taste in your mouth. So what's nice about Jean Gordon's story,
00:02:12.660And I think I say this right away in the interview is it's got a happy ending.
00:02:37.220I was also really happy to talk with Jennifer.
00:02:39.280So please enjoy this discussion of Jean Gordon with Jennifer Morag Henderson.
00:02:44.980Okay, so I'm joined by, like from Scotland, I believe, Jennifer Morag Henderson. Welcome,
00:02:52.040Jennifer. Yeah, thank you. Thanks for inviting me. I am in Inverness in the Highlands of Scotland.
00:02:58.820I'm really excited to talk to you because your book is so interesting. And I'm really excited
00:03:04.020to hear you explain the story, but I'm also excited to talk to a Scottish person in a season
00:03:10.280about Mary Queen of Scots. As a Scottish person, I'm just curious to know, like she's called Mary
00:03:17.780Queen of Scots. For eight years, she was all over Scotland. I think every castle she stayed in now
00:03:24.900has a plaque or something saying she was here, she slept here once. So just in terms of, but she's0.90
00:03:30.200such a French figure as well and I think she kind of for quite a while she wasn't I don't know what's
00:03:38.140her relationship to Scotland now where she how do people in Scotland think about her yes I mean
00:03:43.620it's hard to think that she was only Queen of Scots for such a short time because she had such
00:03:48.820an impact on Scotland I think people here would definitely think of her as Queen of Scots first
00:03:54.720i mean they they would know that she was french she's definitely in the consciousness and yeah
00:04:01.180like as you say there are everywhere that she visited in the whole of scotland they they make
00:04:07.860a thing of that and and people people know all about it everywhere so yes definitely it's just
00:04:13.880it's a i don't know if i can think of a another figure for another country who is you know her
00:04:18.960name is Mary Queen of Scots she there's I would imagine sort of a tourism industry around the
00:04:25.660things she did but she personally had so little to do with the Scottish I don't know national
00:04:32.540character she kind of came from away all these chaotic things happened and then she left I don't
00:04:37.200know I don't know if there's another country with a figure who is so thought about but who is so
00:04:42.320not actually from there yeah that's really interesting I've never thought of that because
00:04:46.540yes you do always just think of her as scottish and yeah you think of her as being taken away to
00:04:52.460france but she's a scot in france but yeah she when she gets back here she doesn't know enough
00:04:59.260about scottish politics and that's like the big problem with her rule is she doesn't know all the
00:05:05.220feuds between the different scottish noblemen and she doesn't know who should be her friend and
00:05:10.700she just she always sees everything in terms of Europe which is one way of looking at how Scottish
00:05:18.700history works at this point in time but yeah you really also need to know because Scotland's such
00:05:24.360a small country really but for such a small country it's got the different parts of Scotland
00:05:30.820are very very different like the highlands of Scotland the far north is really different to
00:05:36.920the northeast. The northeast is really different to the borders. The borders are really different
00:05:42.300to the western highlands. And she didn't really understand that. I think there's like one moment
00:05:49.860in her read where she starts to get that and she could have made it work. But then she kind of
00:05:55.440veers off again and starts thinking about England and what's happening with Elizabeth. But it's
00:06:00.360quite a Scottish tragedy like the kind of being kind of a failure and a tragic figure that's very
00:06:07.400Scottish and actually what you're just talking about I was hoping before we get into the story
00:06:13.520of Jean Gordon if you could explain north north Scotland northeast Scotland how that is so
00:06:19.440different from you know around Edinburgh and things like the clans like and all that sort
00:06:24.360of stuff could you explain sort of how that was functioning during this time yeah so partly it's
00:06:29.880geographic like partly you've got a big mountain range so um you know when you go north you've got
00:06:35.220to get over the mountains it's different land it's like the in in the south of scotland that's
00:06:40.780where the good growing land is so you get um different things can happen there in terms of
00:06:46.600of towns and cities growing up whereas in the far north where jean gordon ends up spending a lot of
00:06:52.360her time it's not good growing land and but then you've also got this kind of you've you've got
00:06:58.220these kind of two systems of government which I talk about in my book and you've got the the kings
00:07:03.260and queen of Scotland um of Scots rather not of Scotland they're kings and queens of the people
00:07:09.040not of the land which is an important distinction so you've got them but you've also got the clans
00:07:13.860and the clan chiefs and the clans it's quite hard to talk about the clans like one of one of the
00:07:20.940reasons I wanted to to research Jean Gordon was I wanted to know about this because there is so
00:07:27.040much mythology around clans and what that means and people wearing tartan and kilts and clan
00:07:34.080chiefs and speaking Gaelic and I really wanted to know what was actually going on at the time
00:07:40.580of Mary Queen of Scots and particularly for Jean Gordon who's in the far north of Scotland which is
00:07:46.200not quite the same as the west of Scotland. The west coast of Scotland is kind of the area where
00:07:53.540the clans are the strongest and remain the strongest for the longest time and that's kind0.94
00:07:58.960of like your images that you would get an outlander you know you've got people wearing
00:08:03.420kilts and tartan and the clan chief is is is in charge yeah this is a little bit complicated so
00:08:10.240historically there was the lord of the isles and the lord of the isles was genuinely as powerful
00:08:16.180as the king of scots so the lord of the isles is that's part of the clan system and it's like a
00:08:22.600a kind of loose alliance of clans and it's going over to Ireland, which is obviously also very,
00:08:29.160very Celtic. You're thinking about the sea as the way that all these things are joined up.
00:08:35.240The Lord of the Isles was defeated by the King of Scots and then the King of Scots is now in charge
00:08:40.980of Scotland. But there were kind of ongoing claimants to be the Lord of the Isles and the
00:08:47.320very last claimant to the lord of the isles dies the same year that gene gordon is born and this
00:08:54.760is really important because it means that throughout gene gordon's lifetime the clans are
00:08:58.760kind of in this state of flux where they're all kind of fighting each other and there's loads of
00:09:03.340clan feuds and really really bloody battles but they're no longer a threat to the king of scots
00:09:09.480or queen of scots as it becomes but they are or they were two different systems they even speak
00:09:16.940different languages. So the Mary Queen of Scots, she speaks Scots, which is a type of English,
00:09:25.280close to English, not quite the same as English. The clans speak Gaelic. But probably at the time
00:09:31.100of Mary Queen of Scots, there was probably, the default would be to speak lots of languages.
00:09:37.400So communication is, we can't, we don't know whether Jean Gordon spoke Gaelic. She definitely0.98
00:09:44.120spoke Scots she probably spoke French she probably had a working knowledge of Latin but we don't know
00:09:48.860if she spoke Gaelic and but we do know that by the time of her grandson he doesn't speak Gaelic
00:09:55.920because the power of the clans is declining as soon as the lordship of the isles is gone and
00:10:00.580the last claimant is gone this is like the slow decline of the clans and I make quite a big thing
00:10:06.480in my book of talking about how there are the clans like the clan Mackay and then Jean sees
00:10:13.280herself as part of the House of Gordon. And the House of Gordon is not a clan. It operates in a
00:10:19.980very similar way to a clan. It's a big family grouping. But their allegiance is to the Queen
00:10:26.280of Scots or King of Scots. And they speak Scots. They don't speak Gaelic. And so I think that leads
00:10:32.160us kind of beautifully into talking about, I think, another important context. Again, we're
00:10:36.920going to talk about Jean Gordon. But can you explain the role that her father had at the time
00:10:42.600that she was born and her father is such a he looms very large he's such an important person
00:10:48.320so can you just describe where he fits into this landscape yes so he he's really really important
00:10:53.840he's one of the most important noblemen in scotland and he has he has a huge amount of power
00:11:00.100in the northeast where he's based that's where he's the edel of huntley and that's where he
00:11:04.780controls loads of land he has loads of families who pay allegiance to him he grew up at court with
00:11:11.100James V, Mary Queen of Scots father, and he's a trusted figure at court. He actually acts as
00:11:19.740regent at more than one point, so he's been trusted to be in charge of the whole of Scotland,
00:11:25.920and he is basically the most powerful Catholic nobleman in Scotland by the time of Mary Queen
00:11:32.500of Scots, because a lot of people by this point have converted to Protestantism, and he's the
00:11:37.600most powerful Catholic nobleman. And he is known as the Cock of the North, or even the King of the
00:11:44.140North. So Jean Gordon grew up in a really, really important household. And you describe in the book
00:11:50.180as well, the castle, which is now, you know, it's sort of a ruin now, I guess, but you really
00:11:55.280describe how fancy it was. Can you talk about Huntley Castle? So Huntley Castle, like what I
00:12:02.900describing the book is Mary of Guise visiting it for the first time and I mean Mary of Guise came
00:12:07.940from France and she's used to really really opulent places and she's in Scotland she's like
00:12:14.180oh it's kind of small the castles are cold so she's on this kind of progress north like the
00:12:21.100further north they went they're getting into the clan lands people are speaking Gaelic like the
00:12:25.640French kind of entourage that she was with they thought like it was pretty backward and then all
00:12:31.680of a sudden they see Huntley Castle. And Huntley Castle is just magnificent. And it is specifically
00:12:39.060designed to look like a French castle because Huntley, Gene Gordon's father, had spent time
00:12:44.480in France. And then he'd come back and he'd used a lot of his money to build a French castle in
00:12:51.520Scotland. And it was, I mean, it's a castle, but it's not one building, like it's a collection of
00:12:57.020buildings so there's several different buildings and they're a big tower house and then they've
00:13:02.940got it kind of arranged so that jean's father has like one floor with a suite of rooms and then
00:13:08.740jean's mother has another floor with a suite of rooms and the castle the castle's still there
00:13:15.200um it is a ruin it's a pretty magnificent ruin because it is it was rebuilt mainly by jean's
00:13:21.720nephew but you still get a sense of just how big it is and how you can still see the the cobbled
00:13:29.200roads that they would have rowed up to to get to the castle and this would have been like Mary of
00:13:34.360Guise would have been traveling along dirt tracks and like sailing and and really like thick wooded
00:13:40.560countryside and really in the middle of nowhere and then all of a sudden there's this cobbled
00:13:45.140path that leads up to this French-looking amazing castle in the Northeast. So Jean Gordon, she is
00:13:53.680born. She's got numerous siblings. So when she's born, what's the lay of the land? What's going on
00:13:59.680there? How are things for her dad and for their family? Yeah, so she has a big family, many
00:14:07.840brothers who are all very close to each other. She is the youngest daughter. She has older sisters,
00:14:14.820the oldest is already married her oldest brother is already married so she's she's she's one of the
00:14:20.280younger ones in the family so her family are doing well at this point I mean her father has
00:14:25.940they they're wealthy they're they're doing well at the Scottish course court and everything
00:14:30.720Scotland itself is is not doing great Jean is almost the same age as Mary Queen of Scots
00:14:38.380so it's kind of that when she's born you know there's the rough wooing and there's kind of
00:14:44.020wars with England. And Jean's father, of course, is involved in all of this, and he is captured
00:14:51.120by the English more than once. But being captured, if you were a nobleman, I mean, it wasn't like
00:14:56.660you got thrown in the worst jail ever. You got kept in quite good conditions. So even if things
00:15:02.340are not great, he is still at the very top of things not being great. So things for the Gordon
00:15:09.060family are still very, very good. Yeah. And so she's growing up, and this is the period of time
00:15:13.720Mary Queen of Scots is in France so it's kind of alternating between who is the regent like Mary
00:15:20.480of Guise is for a while there's also various other men who are doing that so what's the the status at
00:15:26.600this point of like of her Catholic family during the regency era of Mary Queen of Scots? So during
00:15:33.120I mean Mary of Guise obviously wants Scotland to be Catholic and she does kind of she negotiates
00:15:39.920with Jean's father and but the thing is he is so powerful she can't let him get too much power or
00:15:46.540he might be a threat to her so she kind of she kind of she promises him the lands of Murray which
00:15:52.560are the lands that everybody wants their crown lands so Murray isn't at this point passed on
00:15:58.160from father to son it's the king or queen of Scots gets to decide who has Murray and everybody wants
00:16:04.520the lands of Murray because they're really good fertile lands and kind of she kind of strings
00:16:10.340Dean Gordon's father along she's like if you help me and support me to be the regent then I will
00:16:14.860give you the lands of Murray and then once she becomes regent she's like well actually I've
00:16:20.460promised them to somebody else and I don't think you're doing a very good job of keeping the peace
00:16:25.960up in the north of Scotland so maybe you're going to have to help me a bit more before I reward you
00:16:30.860So although he's the most powerful Catholic, Mary of Guise is also trying to keep him so that he's not so powerful that he becomes a threat to her because he has been regent before.
00:16:43.360So obviously she doesn't want him to take over again.
00:16:45.680what would be the next significant thing that happens to her family during genes prior to her
00:16:52.300first marriage which we're going to get to like between being born and that first marriage can
00:16:57.040you sort of explain and I mean your book gets into this in detail but an overview of kind of
00:17:01.340what happens yeah they are like right at the top okay so they're really really powerful and then
00:17:06.780Mary Queen of Scots comes back from France and you would think that she'd be like okay these are the
00:17:11.680most powerful Catholics in Scotland so they might be my allies and that is not what happens at all
00:17:17.120it all goes completely wrong for the Gordons and Jean Gordons father he assumed that he would be
00:17:22.860on Mary Queen of Scots side and he'd said to her you know when you're coming back from France why
00:17:28.140not come to the north of Scotland you can join with me in the northeast and then we'll ride
00:17:32.980down towards Edinburgh but of course she doesn't she lands in Leith and she puts a lot of trust
00:17:39.080in what her half-brother, James Stewart, what he says.
00:22:35.380turning back to her like what was her experience like when that happened would you imagine I mean
00:22:41.720for Jean Gordon herself it must have been pretty traumatic because she would have been
00:22:45.680she I mean everyone in the story is so young I mean Mary Queen of Scots is like 18 at this point
00:22:51.460and Jean Gordon she's about 16 I mean she was at this point she was thinking about who am I going
00:22:57.260to get married to oh I really like this guy Alexander Ogilvy oh things are going to be quite
00:23:02.060good you know like she had all the money she was in this powerful family but she's the youngest
00:23:06.920maybe she can do what she wants a little bit more than her her older siblings um and then0.98
00:23:13.120like all of a sudden they're the queen's enemies and she ends up in Aberdeen watching her brother
00:23:20.760be beheaded and all these rumors are swirling like her brother is the worst person in Scotland
00:23:26.700and he was trying to kidnap Mary Queen of Scots and she knows this isn't what happened and then
00:23:32.960she's taken away from the place where she grew up all of her stuff is taken away she has to move
00:23:38.620down to Edinburgh I mean what what would her mother do it's not like when I say that her and
00:23:44.940her mother have nothing like they have nothing in the sense that they are noble women and at that
00:23:50.140point in time like they would have seen themselves as completely different from people who have no0.99
00:23:55.560money and so would Mary Queen of Scots like she wouldn't have left noble women to starve so what
00:24:01.340they have to do is they have to go to Mary Queen of Scots court they have to go to the court and
00:24:07.740sit with this woman who she's just watched order her brother to be beheaded who's just been the
00:24:14.500cause of her father's death and Jean and her mother end up being like Queen Mary's women they end up
00:24:22.060being sort of like ladies at the court and that must have been yeah that must have been quite
00:24:27.520intense I would say and but the there are I found some descriptions some contemporary descriptions
00:24:34.100of Jean at this time and the descriptions are all extremely positive they all describe her as being
00:24:41.160very quiet you get this impression of of someone who's wearing a mask someone who all their feelings
00:24:48.240are inside and her all her aim at this point is to put on a show put on a good show we've got to
00:24:55.520somehow make things better and you mentioned alex ogilvy can you talk about the the young love yeah
00:25:02.640this is this is one of the things that drew me to to dean gordon's story because she's one of the
00:25:07.800few people at mary queen of scotts court who kind of gets a happy ending and the very first time
00:25:13.360that I kind of noticed her in this story I was reading Antonia Fraser's biography the classic
00:25:19.480biography of Mary Queen of Scots and it's talking about Mary Queen of Scots and Jean Gordon and
00:25:25.040Bothwell and there's a little asterisk and a little footnote and it said Jean Gordon she wanted to
00:25:32.200marry someone else before she married Bothwell she wanted to marry this man called Alex Ogilvie
00:25:36.900and she does get to marry him at the end of her life and have a happy ending and I was like I
00:25:42.820want to know more about that so yeah so there there was this young man called alex ogilvy
00:25:48.220alexander ogilvy who was a minor nobleman um and we know from from various different sources that
00:25:55.440that they had some sort of connection when they were teenagers 16 17 um a very strong connection
00:26:02.380evidently and then yeah so there jean has this very long and very eventful life she actually
00:26:08.820marries three times but at the very end of her life she does marry the man that she loves that
00:26:14.780she has loved since she was a teenager Alex Ogilvy. That's one of the reasons why I'm doing like this
00:26:20.880episode is coming out when it's coming out just because we've gone through Mary Queen of Scots
00:26:25.020and sort of like everything going so wrong I thought let's counterbalance that for a minute
00:26:29.020with somebody who something nice happens to her but but before we get to the something nice
00:26:35.240happening to her let's talk about her first marriage and how that came about because that's
00:26:41.120kind of where she's as you mentioned in the Mary Queen of Scots biography in the historical record
00:26:44.920if anyone prior to reading your book prior to your book being published knew about Jean Gore and they
00:26:49.980knew oh she was the previous wife of Bothwell so how did she end up married to Bothwell yeah so
00:26:56.580this is this is kind of the moment where I think it could have worked for Mary Queen of Scots
00:27:01.720because so everything's kind of gone wrong with Darnley and Mary Queen of Scots has realised that
00:27:07.580her half-brother is maybe not working in her best interests so she starts to look at who's at court
00:27:12.760who's actually on her side and she's like right Bothwell is on my side and the Gordons Jean
00:27:20.200Gordon's family despite everything Mary Queen of Scots did to them they are also on her side
00:27:25.680Jean Gordon's brother and Bothwell are quite good friends and also Bothwell is from the borders
00:27:32.180and Jean Gordon is from the north and this brings two parts of the country together if she can get
00:27:39.680Jean Gordon and Bothwell to marry. So it's a really really clever union that brings together
00:27:45.000two of her strongest supporters who can call on huge amounts of men who could fight for her
00:27:50.820and it brings two parts of the country together and Bothwell has all sorts of connections to the
00:27:57.340north as well because he although he's from the borders he actually grew up partly in the north
00:28:02.660of Scotland with his great uncle in Moray in fact so he has all these connections with with the north
00:28:11.720and he understands it so it could have been a great success if Jean Gordon and Bothwell had
00:28:17.760actually liked each other which they didn't is this a true you say this in your book and whether
00:28:23.760it's true or not it's a good story but wasn't there something like on their wedding night
00:28:27.720jean gordon appeared dressed in like black mourning dress to be like i don't love you
00:28:32.200i will never love you i love alex ogilvy yes i'm in mourning for my lost love i was forced to marry
00:28:39.200you is it true i spent a long time looking for the source for this because it came up in a lot
00:28:45.280of secondary sources and I was like where is this story from I want to know more about this
00:28:49.580it's obviously quite an intimate moment um their honeymoon so I think the source that I could trace
00:28:56.660it back to is um Bothwell's mistress Anna the Scottefruen from Norway the casket letters um
00:29:05.940and you'd probably need like a whole two hours or to go into the casket letters the casket letters
00:29:12.140are probably based on letters that Mary, Queen of Scots wrote, that Jean Gordon wrote, and that one
00:29:18.240of Bothwell's mistresses or former wives, Anna, wrote. And the story about Jean Gordon wearing
00:29:25.140warning clothes seems to come from Anna, because Bothwell had this mistress, and this becomes
00:29:31.720entangled with Jean's story, and they were kind of sniping at each other, and Bothwell was telling
00:29:38.440both of them a lot of details. So yeah, I think it's a very, very good story. There certainly
00:29:45.780seems to have been something very dramatic happen on their honeymoon because it's cut very short
00:29:51.740and Bothwell comes back to Edinburgh to maybe Queen of Scottish Court a lot earlier than planned.
00:29:58.580I'm going to talk about the casket letters in the next episode, but effectively they were letters
00:30:06.340that were later rewritten or reinterpreted as like these were from Mary, Queen of Scots. But
00:30:12.800actually, what you found is they were probably letters from Anna, letters like from Jean,
00:30:19.500like these were the people writing to him, not Mary. Yeah.
00:30:23.020I think they make a lot more sense if you see them in the context of Bothwell's life rather
00:30:27.360than in the context of Mary, Queen of Scots life. Obviously, they're kind of altered and
00:30:32.820used as evidence against Mary Queen of Scots and some of them certainly came from Mary Queen of
00:30:37.460Scots but yeah I use my books all kind of referenced and you can you can follow the
00:30:42.560footnotes to to see where I got where I got the the references for the casket letters but
00:30:47.880yeah there's a there's a biography of Bothwell and which is a very passionate biography which is
00:30:53.580it's quite old now and by a guy called Robert Gore Brown and I very much kind of that was my
00:31:00.020starting point for learning more about Bothwell's life and about his mistresses and about kind of
00:31:04.700exploring the casket letters that way. I will say, and what I have attempted to do in my own
00:31:11.240Mary Queen of Scots episodes, because I'm coming in knowing how the story ends, but a lot of
00:31:16.080listeners don't. So I'm trying to do inspired by what you did in your book to just like, here's
00:31:20.760Bothwell and he's helpful and he's in her corner. Like, I don't want to spoil how it all ends,
00:31:26.360but you do such a good job in your book I was just like wow I've never especially early on
00:31:31.600when he's there and he's by Mary Queen of Scots's side I'm like I've never seen him be treated so
00:31:37.080evenly I guess he's I find Boswell fascinating I mean he raised such strong emotions at the time
00:31:45.620and he still raises such strong emotions now but yeah it's hard to look at his story without
00:31:51.180knowing what happened to him but i think it's really important to see how he was seen when he
00:31:57.840first appears on the scene and how mary would have seen him and and to understand where he's
00:32:02.260coming from and and his background as well side note and we don't need to get into this
00:32:07.700but on the television show rain which i don't know how people in scotland feel about that show
00:32:14.080but there's i thought it was really an interesting choice that the show made when they introduced
00:32:18.860bothwell as a character he's this strapping handsome guy who is helping her and i thought
00:32:24.100what are they doing why would they ever but in your book it's like that's how he comes on the
00:32:28.300scene yeah i would say that i haven't seen rain well that's not true i've seen i managed 10 minutes
00:32:33.720of rain yeah i would say when when he first appears he's he's not he's not how he's seen
00:32:41.820later on and also a lot of how we see him is through the eyes of the like in terms of contemporary
00:32:49.680sources a big contemporary source that everybody uses is the English ambassador's notes and the
00:32:56.000English ambassador does not like Bothwell because Bothwell at a time when people's allegiances were
00:33:02.820often to their religion first Bothwell his allegiance is to Scotland so the English ambassador
00:33:10.140is not going to like him and this partly comes from where he lives because he's he's from the
00:33:14.640borders and the borders are the region that suffer the most when scotland and england fight because
00:33:19.540the fight is obviously going to be on the border so he he sees things differently from a a lot of
00:33:26.480the the lords who who are whose lands are not the ones that are being fought over but he's also i do
00:33:32.320want to mention it's not like he comes in and he's great and then he turns great like he's a he's a
00:33:37.880wild card he is like he's coming into this he's got Anna who is maybe his wife but like they had
00:33:45.080some sort of entanglement he is married to Jean in this and if he and Jean had had a different
00:33:52.680personal relationship things could have gone very differently but they right away clearly don't get
00:33:59.220on with each other he very quickly starts having an affair with one of the servants right yes yeah
00:34:05.640Well, the affair with the servants, that's what's cited in the divorce that he gets from Jean.
00:34:11.080So that's why we know so much about that.
00:34:13.280But yeah, you can't really say, oh, he was the good guy.
00:34:16.620I mean, he's got his own character quirks.
00:34:22.240I find Bothwell so interesting because he's like, here is point A and here is point B.
00:34:28.060And I'm going to go from point A to point B, no matter what is in the way.
00:34:32.740And what is in the way might be other people. You might cause all sorts of problems, all sorts of hurt. But he he has a vision. People with a vision are uncomfortable.
00:34:43.320So we're going to get to how this marriage unravels. I don't know. But if we're just kind of going sequentially, the next major historical event that Jean is tertiarily involved is the murder of Rizzio.
00:34:57.080Yes. So she would have been there that night. Yeah, she would have been in, she was living in, in, in Hollywood at that point, in married quarters with Bothwell. And Bothwell is, yeah, Bothwell is there. Her brother is there. Her mother is really involved in the escape that Mary has to make afterwards.
00:35:18.040so yeah that is that is like another moment when it's the moment where this thing that
00:35:23.820Mary Queen of Scots has set up with Bothwell and Jean it seems to work because she's in trouble
00:35:29.680who's going to come in and save her an alliance of the Gordons and the Borders and it works it yeah
00:35:37.220there's a part in your book where and again I don't want to be like is this true is it not true
00:35:41.540but you say it and it's a great story so in the part where Rizzio has been murdered Mary is sort
00:35:47.400of trapped in a room and she's being sort of held hostage gene's mother comes in with a rope ladder
00:35:53.460in a tray pretending like it's food so she can escape yeah she was um so gene's mother was uh0.65
00:36:01.600one of mary's kind of ladies-in-waiting like person lady who would help her um and she comes
00:36:08.580in and mary queen of scotts is pregnant obviously very very pregnant she's like i'm not feeling0.92
00:36:13.900great someone's going to have to check me jean gordon's mother she had what like 12 14 children
00:36:20.620so she's like right i i will go with her to the to the toilet and we will we will make sure
00:36:25.840everything is okay and she's and she goes in and she's like right i can take a note to my son and
00:36:31.360to bothwell and then we can get and then i will come back in later and and how are we going to
00:36:35.960do this how are we going to escape i will bring a rope ladder in and we will and you can escape
00:36:40.720down the rope ladder and Mary Queen of Scots is like I'm six months pregnant I'm not going to
00:36:46.040escape down a rope ladder um I will write a letter with instructions get the letter to your son and
00:36:51.740to Bothwell and we will we will that's when she decides to speak to Darnley and get out that way
00:36:57.160but yeah and Jean's mother was like yeah we'll get a rope ladder we'll get out that way I've
00:37:01.200had 14 kids you could totally do it yeah that I love that detail and I love that uh just especially
00:37:09.220the first part of gene's life is so entwined with what's happening with mary queen of scotts like
00:37:15.160the fact she's there the night that that murder happens and the fact that her like again this is
00:37:19.380a part where it's kind of like oh this is working the gene bothwell marriage brought together these
00:37:24.460groups and that's part of why mary was able to escape yeah and then and then she's there as well
00:37:30.120the night that darnley dies um she is bothwell's alibi for the night that darnley dies they say
00:37:36.560where were you and he said I was in bed with my wife for most of the night so yes she is right in
00:37:42.960the middle of court and and she would have known everything that was going on I mean the stories
00:37:47.760that she must have had I imagine her as an older woman with her own children like she must have
00:37:55.200been able to tell them so much and so the Darnley actually you described this in a really interesting
00:38:01.540way I hadn't thought about this before in this way the fact that Darnley's death is because of
00:38:07.500an explosion that was the first time what okay his death was mysterious but an explosion was
00:38:14.100involved whether or not that's what killed him but that was shocking to everybody because like
00:38:19.380not a bomb but just like gunpowder that had never been used in that way right yeah so this is one of
00:38:25.480the really interesting things about this period in history like it's it's the early modern period
00:38:30.940And one of the things that makes it modern is the advances in weapons and gunpowder and guns.
00:49:57.380And we host I Think Not, a true crime comedy podcast covering some of the wildest stories from your favorite true crime campy TV shows all the way to Unsolved Mysteries.
00:50:10.380You'll think about true crime in a whole new way.
00:50:12.540And you'll also ask yourself, who gave these people mics?
00:50:15.360New episodes of I Think Not are released every Wednesday with bonus episodes out every Thursday on Patreon.
00:50:21.360And every Monday, you can listen to our True Crime Rundown, where we go over the top true crime headlines of the week.
00:50:28.960So come and join us wherever you listen to your podcasts.
00:50:33.800Ever get to the end of a podcast episode and think, now what?
00:50:38.160Well, instead of scrolling through a million choices, try Something You Should Know.
00:50:42.920I'm the host, Mike Carruthers, and every episode is packed with fascinating, useful, and surprising things you'll actually use in your life.
00:50:50.780from human behavior, relationships, health, science, and everyday mysteries.
00:50:56.760So while you're already in your podcast app, just search for Something You Should Know
00:51:01.600and listen to an episode right now, Something You Should Know.
00:51:20.780because Agnes is married to Mary, Queen of Scots, half-brother, James Stuart, the Errol of Murray.
00:51:26.880So she goes to Agnes and she says, I don't want anything more to do with Bothwell.
00:51:31.740I'm completely innocent and all of this. And also I'm going home to the northeast.
00:51:36.940And that it kind of gets her out of the situation.
00:51:39.380And she's kind of publicly allied herself with Murray, who's who's in the ascendant.
00:51:46.020Yeah. And then she goes back up to the northeast where her brother is now the Errol of Huntley,
00:51:50.200back to Huntley Castle where she grew up. What I appreciated in this story that I don't often see
00:51:56.500in the women whose stories I research is that her family was always there for her and helped her.
00:52:02.740So I appreciated that she had a place that she could go and that the Gordons were family first,
00:52:08.520like no matter what had happened, Jean always had a support system.
00:52:12.660She seems to, like they seem as a group of siblings, all these absolutely terrifying
00:52:17.380brothers that she had they seem to have been particularly close and one of the sources that
00:52:24.040we have for this is Jean's son who she has eventually Robert writes a family history
00:52:29.280and he kind of describes the Gordon siblings as being like really really close like even at a
00:52:36.840time when family was everything because that family was absolutely everything in the 16th
00:52:41.380century in Scotland even at a time when family was everything this was a close family. She was
00:52:46.980probably brought up closely with her brothers and educated alongside them she had a very good
00:52:51.360education because it's a high point for girls education and yeah they are there for her when
00:52:56.760when she needs them her brother george because everyone is called george and but her brother
00:53:01.860george who's now the edel he he was bothwell's friend and bothwell comes to him and says can
00:53:07.980you help me and he says no because of what you've done to my sister so yeah so when it came down to
00:53:13.940it was he going to help his friend or his sister he was going to help his sister he was going to
00:53:18.080help Jean that it's just it's really rare and it's this is again where I feel like gee there's
00:53:24.840obviously so much drama and stuff but this is to me in the context of this podcast a nice story
00:53:30.520yes I mean apart apart from all the blood and feuds and and horrific injuries yeah but they do
00:53:37.900They have the kind of image of these strong brothers and Jean and her sisters as well, because they stand up for her other sister, Margaret.
00:53:47.640Her older sister, Elizabeth, is dead by this point, but her sister, who's closer to her in age, the brothers stand up for her as well.
00:53:57.020And they help her sort out her marriage, which also goes horribly wrong.
00:54:01.600And you just get this impression of this strong family.
00:54:04.620there are some descriptions of of gene's brother george kind of playing football with the with the
00:54:11.500men in huntley castle and having meals with them and you just get this impression of of this really
00:54:17.940convivial family group who genuinely got on with each other again like all the details are in your
00:54:24.400book but if we're just going to kind of like focus on gene and her story the next thing that kind of
00:54:28.840what happens that affects her in a profound way is that she thinks both well is dead which gives
00:54:34.920her the freedom now whether she believed that she was divorced or not to now find a new husband or
00:54:39.980makes her family realize that like gene could maybe be remarried this is the part in your book
00:54:46.000listeners this is such uh i was reading this book with the frantic pace that i usually read like a
00:54:52.360psychological thriller or murder mystery because jennifer puts these cliffhanger endings at the
00:54:56.900ends of chapters and you say something like to explain about gene's next husband first let's move
00:55:01.640back a bit i need to tell you the story of a poisoning and my my break at work was over and i
00:55:06.980thought i can't i can't put down this book she's going to tell me the story of a poisoning so but
00:55:12.300explain who her next husband is please yeah i mean there are so many like the stories around
00:55:18.640mary queen of scott's life are well known but the stories around dean gordon's life they're amazing
00:55:23.440and the Helmsdale poisoning and what happens to her, her future husband is just, I mean,
00:55:29.340even people in Scotland don't know these stories so well. And it's just like, you need to know this
00:55:33.860because it is such a good story. But yeah, she does, she remarries, when she believes Bothwell
00:55:40.140is dead, to the Errol of Sutherland, who is Alexander Gordon. Alexander Gordon, the Errol
00:55:48.820of Sutherland has this dramatic escape and there's the poisoning and there's all sorts of stuff
00:55:52.420happens and so he's had this kind of traumatic life and also former forced marriage and Jean's
00:55:58.980had this traumatic life and forced marriage with so these two people kind of find each other
00:56:04.020and they get married and it's a happy marriage this isn't the man that she was in love with
00:56:09.520when she was a teenager this is someone else and this is she would have believed at the time this
00:56:14.060was it this was the person she was going to marry this was going to be the rest of her life
00:56:17.620And it turns out really, really well. And they are happy. And so she moves over to the far north of Scotland. So that's north of where I am here in Inverness. And they live at Dunrobin Castle. And she's the Countess of Sutherland. And she does all sorts of things because her husband is not really, she's the power.
00:56:40.500She and her brothers, the Gordons, are the power.
00:56:43.780And she does all these incredible things.
00:58:03.580So what she's doing essentially is you get a big pan and you put loads of seawater in it and you boil off the water and you're left with the salt.
00:58:11.300In order to do this, you need a ready source of fuel.
00:58:14.580But she knew that there was a coal mine.
00:58:18.080There was a seam of coal near to where she was now living with her new husband, the Earl of Sutherland.
00:58:23.380so she sets up a coal mine and they can dig the coal and use the coal to boil off the seawater
00:58:30.260to make salt she can then sell the salt they were selling it as far as as far away as France
00:58:36.260and not just selling salt but also selling things like salted fish so there's lots of fish in the
00:58:43.180rivers round about so they're catching the fish they're salting the fish they can then pack it and
00:58:46.920send it on boats and sell it and you're making money yeah which is a big thing i think this is
00:58:53.740where in your book you have like part one and then part two but to me slash to the average you know
00:58:59.780history aficionado if you've heard of jean gore and it's like yeah she was the previous wife of
00:59:04.700bothwell and so everything we just talked about like she was all up in the mary queen of scott
00:59:08.580story but then the whole rest of your book is like and then she did other stuff too and it's
00:59:14.900not like it slows down i mean it keeps on going because there's there's all the stuff with the
00:59:21.020she's doing with salt but there's also this whole other story with the clan makai that's going on
00:59:27.140as well yeah how long do you have i could talk about this for hours well and this is the thing
00:59:33.560this is where like we got to the like the mary could have scott stuff i was just like i know that
00:59:37.640story in another context so just seeing what gene's involvement was like okay this part yeah
00:59:42.020Darnley Bothell okay and then this stuff where you're just like what was happening here's what
00:59:47.240I know now which is just that Scottish history is really exciting like there's always a rivalry
00:59:52.980there's always a murder poisoning is involved like it's it's it's a very action-packed what's
01:00:01.140going on in Scotland yes it's there's a lot going on and I think the the history of the north of
01:00:08.760Scotland because eventually over time like the north of Scotland the the population is much
01:00:13.440smaller up here now and but at the time that Jean Gordon was living that hadn't happened yet the
01:00:17.920clearances hadn't happened yet so but because of everything that's happened since the history of
01:00:23.520the far north of Scotland is really understudied and I really like obviously my own way into the
01:00:31.220story was Mary Queen of Scots and I was interested in Mary Queen of Scots but then I was interested
01:00:35.860in the North because I'm from the North. And I just became, I was like, you know, the bit with
01:00:41.160Mary Queen of Scots is interesting, but there's all this other stuff, which is also fantastic.
01:00:47.260And there's just the stories and you get such a strong impression of the personalities of everyone
01:00:55.260involved. And it seems, I wanted to tell all the stories because they just, they seem so real,
01:01:01.260like they are real but but it's it's so modern like one of my main sources for my book was Jean
01:01:07.820Gordon's own letters like written in her own handwriting and I was I was reading these letters
01:01:14.840and it's this really weird balance between things that we know about from history books
01:01:20.160and then she's also talking about her servant and so-and-so's baby and oh did you hear about this
01:01:27.260and half the stuff she's talking about is stuff that you know and the rest of it is just like
01:01:32.380this family story and I love that mixture of the the kind of grand stories of history
01:01:39.060and not just Scottish history but European history but then also it was a very very personal thing
01:01:44.960and there's so many colorful characters like if I think of your book it's like kind of or
01:01:50.260Jean Gorn's life really it's kind of like from birth until the end of her marriage to Bothwell
01:01:55.840is kind of one era and then the whole rest of her life which is a much longer period of time
01:02:01.760it's this northern scotland stuff and it's just like when i talk about the cliffhangers in your
01:02:06.420book it's not just like okay now she's married she has these salt pans everything it's like no
01:02:10.340no there's still drama is still happening there's still you've got these really colorful characters
01:02:15.240with great names you've got the wizard earl you've got his brother the wicked earl you've got the
01:02:21.160Herod of the North. You've got it just. Yeah. I mean, everyone's called George. So I had to find0.68
01:02:28.020a way to distinguish everybody. But all of the names, I was saying this to you before, all of
01:02:32.220the names are contemporary names. And particularly up here, like by names are kind of, they're kind
01:02:39.840of still a thing. Like there's a lot of people with the same name. So you never just say, oh,
01:02:44.240it's Donald. It's always, oh, Donald the taxi, you know, that's the guy that drives the taxi.
01:02:49.040So her grandson, for example, is Donald of the Troubles, which gives you a little bit of an insight into what happens to poor Donald, who I like very much.
01:02:59.560But yeah, these kind of bi-names, they were contemporary names, and I think they hopefully really helped the reader to picture them.
01:03:16.700Yeah, Dark Uyston of the Battleaxe. That is who Jean marries her daughter to, Dark Uyston of the Battleaxe. Would you want to marry your daughter to someone called that? But yeah, I like Uyston as well. He is Donald of the Tribbles' father. So yeah, he was the chief of Mackay. This is where the clan history really gets going.
01:03:39.660and so Jean's married life so her husband is I think ill a lot of the time which is part of why0.70
01:03:48.280she I don't know if that's part of why she really stepped up or just like she finally was in a
01:03:52.920position where this is what she was like and this is what she wanted to do and she did it but they
01:03:57.120had this successful marriage I think a bit of both yeah yeah yeah definitely I mean he can't
01:04:04.280of been too sickly because he does lead his men into battle but in order to be an edel at that
01:04:09.740time you had to be like super fit because you were going to be on the battlefields you were
01:04:13.980going to be leading from the front so certainly towards the end of his life he does seem to have
01:04:18.460some health problems which is partly why she marries her daughter to dark uiston of the
01:04:23.280battle axe because they need a strong ally but yeah she is very much kind of using at this point
01:04:30.520in Scottish history as well kind of people are moving away from just hacking at each other with
01:04:35.220swords they're trying to settle things a bit more like through the courts and sensibly and as a woman0.99
01:04:41.000that's what she can do like she can she can come in through the courts and try and do things on0.99
01:04:45.940paper and do things legally um and and she really manages to to use that as a strength and really0.98
01:04:53.300she she kind of helps to manage the estates for her husband and then when he dies she manages the
01:04:58.740estates in the minority of her son. Unfortunately, he inherits his father's constitution. So she ends
01:05:05.220up managing the estates in the minority of her grandson as well. So it's basically this one woman0.97
01:05:11.960in charge for three generations. And any analysis that looks only at the male line of the Edels of0.98
01:05:18.380Sutherland misses a huge part of the story because it is this one woman in charge. And I think part
01:05:24.540of it as well because it's her second marriage and she's a little bit older she's just like
01:05:28.880we're not going to do all that nonsense like what happened with Bothwell we're just going to go for
01:05:33.780it and her her mother is incredible all the women in her family are incredible they're all these
01:05:39.320really really strong-minded capable estate managers and she's she's just really really1.00
01:05:47.600good at that and quite ruthless actually not always in the in the nicest way. Just as a
01:05:53.740contrast I find this really interesting from reading your book and reading about her experience
01:05:58.260and her mother just her family and the other women involved like that to me seems like that's0.93
01:06:03.340that's the history of women in Scotland is these kind of like women who grew up kind of rough and
01:06:08.220tumble you know around the brothers and then crazy chaos is happening around them constantly
01:06:14.100there's all these feuds but they're all kind of strong like they're up for the challenge
01:06:17.520and then you've got the national heroine Mary Queen of Scots who that's not her constitution
01:06:23.060like nothing against Mary Queen of Scots but that wasn't her experience that's not the kind of person0.99
01:06:26.880she was like I would think that a Scottish heroine would be more of the Jean Gordon style than the
01:06:32.340Mary Queen of Scots who was just kind of she had her skillset and we talked about that three hours
01:06:37.040of podcasting so far but it's a completely different kind of person yeah I think I think
01:06:42.580there's the kind of the moment where Bothwell abducts maybe I kind of I started to change how
01:06:50.340I thought about that when I realised that Bothwell was with his sister, Janet, and his former lover,
01:06:56.260also called Janet. And those two women were just like, why is Mary Queen of Scots making so much
01:07:02.700fuss? You just have to get on with it. And they both had these horrific things happen to previous1.00
01:07:09.460husbands and they buried husbands and they were living in this violent country in this violent
01:07:14.780time and they were tough whereas mary queen of scots is brought up in the french court where you
01:07:21.720just don't have to be like that so yeah i mean jean gordon she's brought up in luxury in scotland
01:07:27.460but she's brought up in an area which is full of feuding clansmen she knows you have to be tough0.95
01:07:33.500it's just constitutionally jean gordon was the right sort of person to be living the life she
01:07:40.420was living I think. Yes you can see you can see how the Gordons got so much power when you look
01:07:48.060at her and her brothers. And so she has various children and then eventually she is widowed her
01:07:54.780second husband passes away and coincidentally her long-lost childhood love Alex Ogilvie
01:08:02.440also widowed at around the same time and then what happens? Yeah he he married one of the four
01:08:09.560Mary's, the famous attendants who supported Mary, Queen of Scots. He married Mary Beaton
01:08:15.140and she dies. And so he's a widower and she's a widow. And they're like, nothing is in our way
01:08:22.500anymore. We can have the teenage dream. We can finally get married. And they do.
01:16:38.840and as do her brothers and their children.
01:16:42.000I love that well I don't love that but what I love is that this is evidence that she did not
01:16:49.020decide but you know I'm 80 years old I'm just gonna kind of hang back and just go with the1.00
01:16:53.360flow no she was like excommunicated because she was harboring Catholics like she was just0.88
01:16:57.840non-stop this is she doesn't stop it's not like she she retires into the background quietly she0.88
01:17:05.380She is, I mean, her brother James was probably the last serious threat to Protestantism in Scotland.
01:17:14.780Not a very serious threat because it was very entrenched by that time.
01:17:18.120But yeah, a lot of stuff is still going on with James VI and her family end up.
01:17:26.180It's a little bit like her father in that they end up on his side and then against him.
01:17:31.380And they go from the very top to the very bottom again.
01:17:34.260And yeah, a lot is going on. And there's a Gordon Murray feud, a very long blood, a very bloody blood feud that takes up quite a lot of the second half of my book.
01:17:46.920At what age was it that she passed away and from what?
01:17:49.880um so she dies of old age in her bed yeah in her in her early 80s and she was buried with
01:17:57.880the full ceremony that would normally be given to a male ero yeah she got the she got the full
01:18:04.580respect from her from her children and the people around her i don't often get to say this on this
01:18:10.520podcast but it was a life well lived you know yes yeah she she she got everything she could
01:18:17.480she she was such a good subject for a biography I think yeah to you what a gift of I mean I'm sure
01:18:27.120you know all the work that you needed to do to find all this information but sometimes in the
01:18:31.660biographies that I read for this podcast or just for fun you know there's an exciting part of their
01:18:35.880life it's like and then for the next 25 years she managed the home and you know it's just which is
01:18:41.480nice for her that's a nice life to have but you just had in this story like so many things kept
01:18:48.000happening around her and she was always tertiary involved in in so much drama yeah i mean she's
01:18:56.160involved she's involved as a woman she is managing the home but she is managing like she's managing
01:19:02.480dunrobin castle in the middle of loads of hostile clans and an ongoing feud with the edels around
01:19:09.760about her whilst promoting her religion and yeah she's she's managing the home was exciting
01:19:18.100there was a lot going on yes exactly she did manage a home for for numerous years but it wasn't
01:19:24.320just you know choosing staff and I don't know decorate choosing a curtain fabric definitely
01:19:31.520not so I know that you have listened to some of my episodes before so you're familiar with
01:19:36.300I do a scoring at the end. It's the Fredegund Memorial Scandalicious Scale. So there's four
01:19:42.600categories. I'm going to entirely let you choose the numbers because you're so intimately familiar
01:19:47.060with this subject, but I'll just sort of explain what the categories are and then you can think
01:19:51.220about in the context. Because we're thinking of her not in the context of her compared to anyone
01:19:56.800else that I've talked about on the podcast, but just her in her life and how she was seen by the
01:20:02.360people around her so the first category is scandalousness which just means did any was she
01:20:08.960seen as a scandalous person by anyone in her life my instinct is to say not really no not really
01:20:17.580I mean she was scandal adjacent but she was blameless in it yeah she she does a very good
01:20:26.480job of presenting herself as completely blameless at all times possibly slightly scandalous towards0.93
01:20:33.960the end of her life because even her own son says she had an almost masculine understanding
01:20:40.760and he kind of he talks around like why is this woman in charge of everything when normally it's
01:20:47.180a man so I think people had started to notice by the end of her life that she she'd done some
01:20:53.160pretty unusual things but yeah most of the time not very scandalous no and I guess what in terms0.94
01:21:00.160of harboring fugitive Catholics that would be seen as scandalous to Protestant people so that's true0.53
01:21:06.160but like on a scale of zero to ten how what would you score her for scandalousness um I'm not sure0.80
01:21:14.720maybe quite low like four or five yeah maybe like four not very scandalous yeah there's some there's
01:21:21.600some there but there's not a lot and you know to her credit that's why she was able to live into
01:21:26.800her 80s because yep well and the fact that she got out of the Bothwell Mary Queen of Scots
01:21:33.640situation with her name and reputation intact I think speaks well of her family connection
01:21:41.000but also her yeah because poor Bothwell ends up in a terrible place yeah no we we talk about
01:21:48.120in my episode about that. Actually, side note, when we were emailing each other arranging this
01:21:55.640interview, you had mentioned that you find him, Bothwell, a fascinating person. You have sort of
01:22:00.820a chapter in your book that is, what happened to Bothwell? Because, you know, we kind of have to
01:22:05.540tie that up. What do you think about him? Well, first of all, it's a sequence of improbable
01:22:12.360coincidences that led him to being trapped in that it's Norway right in this like dungeon prison
01:22:19.500yeah I mean first Norway and then eventually Denmark towards the end yeah he gets moved around
01:22:25.320a wee bit in Scandinavia but yeah I mean it's it's it's like the worst possible karma whatever
01:22:31.600he did and he did some pretty awful things I mean he gets punished for it and just to end up in in
01:22:40.180that horrible, horrible dungeon. Such an active man to be trapped in that way. It's just, I find
01:22:48.560it very sad. And I mentioned that there was this Bothwell biography that I read by Robert Gore
01:22:55.520Brown, which is quite a revisionist kind of, I don't know if you've read, my first biography
01:23:01.100that I wrote was a biography of a crime writer called Josephine Tay. I don't know if you've
01:23:07.080heard of her i've heard of her i haven't read your book yet yet yeah josephine tay wrote um her best
01:23:13.280known novel is the daughter of time which is this kind of it's very hard to describe it's this kind
01:23:18.520of revisionist it's a murder mystery but it's it's this kind of revisionist thing about richard
01:23:23.300the third and how he wasn't a monster um so this this biography of of bothwell um is kind of like
01:23:31.220revisionist and that it's like he's not a monster and it went into some detail about how about the
01:23:37.400prison and what happened and and the karma that that he was served and the i found that such a
01:23:45.220striking image in this biography where the author visited the castle where bothwell was imprisoned
01:23:53.200and his bothwell's body was mummified by the sea air and it was on display for years and and there's
01:24:02.360a very vivid description of it um and then I was kind of got to know these other people who were
01:24:10.060very very keen on history and and eventually kind of got to know there was a a wee group of people
01:24:15.900in Scotland who who thought it might be a good idea if bothwell's body was brought back to Scotland
01:24:22.140and one of the people involved in this was a descendant of Bothwell,
01:24:27.800slightly sideways, obviously, because he doesn't have children with Jean or anybody.
01:24:32.240And he described to me how he ended up visiting Bothwell's tomb
01:24:38.740and eventually Bothwell's body was placed in a closed tomb.
01:24:44.720And he gave me this very vivid description of finally going there
01:24:48.920and this was his ancestor and he knew all the history.
01:24:52.140And he thought it might be a good idea to bring him back.
01:24:54.460And then he was like, I just felt this sense of peace that we brought attention to this story and that that was what needed to be done, that the story needed to be told.
01:25:05.700Yeah, it's all in my book. I explain it better. I'm better at writing than speaking.
01:25:10.240But yeah, it's just history means so much to so many people.
01:25:14.400People get so into it, so worked up about it.
01:25:18.120so it's their ancestors and it's part of their part of how they see themselves and it's just I
01:25:24.780love it I love all the passion I love I love how intimate people are I really appreciate in your
01:25:31.580book like you're very even-handed I think in describing the Bothwell situation and I'm you
01:25:38.520know I went into your book coming in hot you know I hate Darnley now I hate Mary's half-brother and
01:25:44.280I'm just like oh Bothwell he sucks and it's like yes but also isn't this interesting and also he
01:25:50.440I think paid for what he did so we don't need to keep and you can kind of like I mean you can kind0.97
01:25:57.320of be flippant when you're talking about like kings and queens and things that happened 500
01:26:01.480years ago but you also have to remember that they were real people and they really they suffered and
01:26:07.760they loved and they yeah I mean like my because my first biography of Josephine T
01:26:13.720occasionally people come to talks that I've given about Josephine T and they tell me that
01:26:18.960they know her or they were related to her or they know people that I've written about
01:26:22.580so I was very aware that I'm writing about real people and even with this book it's 500 years ago
01:26:29.180but when I was researching in archives often I'd have to go to family archives
01:26:33.740and I did go to the Errol of Murray's castle for example where the current Errol of Murray is like
01:26:40.800you can he can trace his descendants descendants from from Mary's half-brother so I was although
01:26:47.420it's 500 years ago they were real people and yeah you have to you have to think about that and yeah
01:26:55.040yeah and what does that if that's someone's ancestor what does that mean to them versus
01:27:00.640it's just, oh, it's a character in a novel or it's a story. It's like, no, this was like a person.
01:27:05.260Yeah. I wanted to tell it like story. That's how people respond to life is through stories. But
01:27:11.800I never wanted to lose sight of the fact that these were real people.
01:27:16.220And I think that's a real, like part of what made your book so compelling to me and I think
01:27:21.700to other people is that combination of like your storytelling is so propulsive. You know,
01:27:27.920I can't wait to read the next chapter. But at the same time, yeah, I think you kind of you you
01:27:32.780respect the people you're talking about, which I also appreciate. The next category on our scale
01:27:37.800is I call it scheminess. You know, it's basically so all the categories can start with an S. The
01:27:42.420word I chose is scheminess. So what it means is if we're thinking about schemes, but in terms of
01:27:46.980like, it's not a negative necessarily, it's just like coming up with plans, being resilient, you
01:27:51.700know, being an active person, you know, like if you're backed in a corner coming up with a clever
01:27:57.160thing to do or and i think this is she could score high on this like the the salt pans like
01:28:03.620always landing on her feet like figuring out what to do in a variety of bizarre situations but
01:28:10.240i think she was a very thoughtful person and a very intelligent person yeah definitely intelligent
01:28:15.620well educated and she knows which direction she's going in she's got goals gordons must come first
01:28:22.500yeah and she she puts plans into place executes them brilliantly so yeah she's not a she's not a
01:28:29.880sort of sideways schemey person very direct person um but yeah quite high quite high maybe
01:28:37.540maybe seven or eight less because she's not kind of i think of schemey as being like quite devious
01:28:43.380and she's not devious at all yeah but i think i'm comfortable with an eight for scheminess
01:28:48.800the next category and I'm interested to hear what you're going to say I've got some thoughts based
01:28:53.680on what you've been saying significance like my first thought was what you said about the
01:28:59.200significance of the coal mine and the salt pans to industry in northern Scotland it sounds like
01:29:05.720that was a significant thing she did but it's also her historic her significance not necessarily to
01:29:13.100like world history because that's not the sort of life she was living but just to her significance
01:29:19.840you know it drew you to write a biography of her so what what do you think yeah i would i would put
01:29:25.840her significance pretty high for the north of scotland she created the house of sutherland
01:29:32.540and the house of sutherland had then such a massive influence throughout the subsequent years
01:29:39.220on what happens in the north of Scotland.
01:29:42.240So yeah, I think it's got to be quite high
01:30:06.440the same sequence of events wouldn't have happened.
01:30:08.280i'm comfortable with a nine for significance i think and that was where i really i'm relying on
01:30:13.060you for all of these numbers obviously but you know the history of northern scotland to an extent
01:30:18.460that i do not so i don't exactly the house of southern that's good to know that that and the
01:30:23.400coal the coal mines existed in brora until the 1970s really yes not i mean it kind of died and
01:30:33.320got revived three or four times I think altogether but yeah yeah a big and yeah for people thinking
01:30:39.640the highlands are are kind of remote um yeah they weren't well and also just gonna say after this
01:30:47.280I'm like really excited to learn more about it's the same way as when I first read about I don't
01:30:51.980know the history of Angola or Peru for the first time I was just like oh this is great like northern
01:30:58.160Scotland like I think when I was reading your book I was like wow you know I felt like oh yeah
01:31:02.420I know about Scottish history, but I don't because everything I'd read until your book was about the border area, like Edinburgh and really Scotland in relation to England is what I know.
01:31:13.260And that's an entirely different story from like the clans and what was happening up north.
01:31:17.380So I'm excited to learn more about that because clearly it's really dramatic and exciting.
01:31:25.260Yes, there's a lot. But yeah, not enough about the north of Scotland, I think. I think there should be more.
01:31:30.500definitely definitely well it's like honestly my concept of Scotland before I was researching this
01:31:37.160Mary Queen of Scots season I was just thinking okay have you seen the the Saoirse Ronan Mary
01:31:42.420Queen of Scots movie yes I went to see that with one of my good friends who is a professor of
01:31:47.440history and we had a great time we were in hysterics we were like whispering pointing out
01:31:53.600all the historical inaccuracies we particularly liked the men from Thurso we had a lot of thoughts
01:32:00.260about that yeah the denim dresses yeah a great film we had a great time possibly not in the way
01:32:06.260the filmmakers intended I think that's one I'm definitely going to cover on vulgar peace theater
01:32:11.280where I do where I talk about costume dramas with my friends but when I was reading your book I was
01:32:15.600thinking about because I for various reasons and it's most of what I know about Scottish history
01:32:19.400is from pop culture basically you know like I don't know brigadoon things like that so I just
01:32:25.600sort of thought how even outlander like i know it's the highlands but i just sort of conflated
01:32:30.080everything so it's like mary queen of scots you know she gets to scotland and she comes to the
01:32:34.180scottish court and i was picturing them like in the saoirse ronan movie her brother her half
01:32:38.720brother he looks like mel gibson is braveheart he's got like dreadlocks eyeliner yeah no they
01:32:45.800looked the hair the big hair no they would have had neat hair they would have not wanted to look
01:32:52.020like Klansmen definitely yeah yeah we had we had fun with that no exactly so like in my defense0.54
01:32:58.460the reason why I was imagining Mary Queen of Scots or even Marie de Guise or Margaret Tudor
01:33:03.220coming to Scotland and I pictured the people who they would meet would look like that
01:33:07.060but I have since been told by um my friend who also is in Scotland but also just from your book
01:33:14.760and just from reading I'm like oh no like Edinburgh was like people there like they would look the same
01:33:20.000as they looked in England effectively like tidy hair courtly dress yeah yeah so I don't okay good
01:33:26.900I was I was wondering what you thought about the portrayal of James Stewart in that film as kind of
01:33:31.620a wild highland looking guy yeah no he would have been nothing nothing like that at all there are
01:33:38.320portraits of him looking very dressed in black and very proper yeah it's so for me I guess it's
01:33:48.000similar to other regions I've read about where my understanding of them is so much based just on
01:33:52.780movies I've happened to watch or that sort of thing and then when you read the history you're
01:33:56.200like oh this is wrong and I see why people from that country don't like this because yeah but
01:34:02.260there were clansmen there were clansmen in kilts speaking Gaelic yeah that that was a big part of
01:34:10.040Scotland's history as well it's just that that didn't happen absolutely everywhere it's yeah
01:34:16.680for for a small country it's got a lot of different areas with a lot of complex history
01:34:21.980going on in each separate area yeah and the men like the highlanders in the kilts speaking gallic
01:34:28.220were not in royal court advising mary queen of scots no yes well okay yeah so yes later in my
01:34:38.380book donald of the tribbles who is dean gordon's grandson and also the chief of mackay he does go
01:34:44.700to court in london to meet james vi but he would not have worn a kilt to do that he would have
01:34:50.240worn there's descriptions of him he would have worn like a slash doublet um but when he was back
01:34:56.260up north he probably wore a kilt then yeah because there's pictures of him in europe because he ends
01:35:02.940up in the 30 years war which you definitely don't want to get into but yeah then they're wearing
01:35:07.480plaid with like the old-fashioned kilt yeah so yeah outlander style i grew up in culloden like
01:35:14.940i grew up next to the battlefield so that's why i'm interested in history you would be like oh
01:35:20.340my gosh yeah whether one believes in ghosts or not i think there's just so much history you could
01:35:25.220feel when you're around there every day um the last category and i'm not sure how she's gonna
01:35:31.220how this is gonna go so the last category is what i call the sexism bonus and what that is there for
01:35:37.420it's not so much in her story but if you think about a story of I don't know the sort of woman1.00
01:35:43.760who maybe did something scandalous and then got locked away for 25 years and had no freedom or
01:35:49.200somebody who just didn't have any opportunities in life it's the sexism bonus it's a way to give
01:35:52.960points to those people who maybe didn't get the opportunity to scheme or to be scandalous but
01:35:59.160also we just consider it like how much did sexism get in her way and I would say very little yeah
01:36:05.000very very little I was really interested when writing my biography to kind of think about what
01:36:10.320life was like for women in Scotland and even just legally the position is really different to women
01:36:16.620in England women were in like things like when they were widowed women in England could be left
01:36:22.620with nothing in Scotland they were they had something so yeah very low I would say about
01:36:28.420one on that score maybe yeah I mean maybe maybe two for being with Boswell and Boswell's mistresses
01:36:36.100yeah Boswell yeah maybe she should get more for that I think so having to deal with being married0.59
01:36:41.380to Boswell but yeah and that was also interesting to see the difference in just culturally well even
01:36:46.140the fact like her brothers supported her the fact that when Boswell went for help they sided with
01:36:50.940her instead of him I could see in another cultural context a woman's brother might have sided with
01:36:55.540the husband because they're like, well, you're the man, you know, but in her situation, family
01:36:59.580trumps everything. Like it's all about family, whether it's a girl or a boy, like family is
01:37:06.400number one. Also Bothwell's Protestant and she's Catholic, but her brother kind of was a Protestant
01:37:13.880at one point, but then switches back to being Catholic. So yeah, so that's going on as well.
01:37:19.400So her total then is 23, which on it's, I don't know, I do the score at the end just because it's a way to sort of wrap things up. But it's she's certainly that's not the lowest score. Like Boudicca, the queen of the Roman. She has a 23. So like she's in good company there. Lola Montez. I don't know if you know her. She's got a 23. So it's interesting. Like it's rare for somebody to score high in all four categories.
01:37:47.660but a 23 generally means you live a good life and nothing and you did okay for yourself if you're a
01:37:55.540high scandalousness that also goes with sort of a very stressful situation i think and actually
01:38:00.300there's one more thing i wanted to ask you so there's another category that i've added it's
01:38:06.280called the lady jane seymour memorial award for outstanding supporting performance it's named
01:38:11.160after lady jane seymour who is the best friend of lady catherine gray jane gray's sister just
01:38:16.960because lady jane seymour was a really good best friend and by the time i did that episode it was
01:38:22.920rare for me to find somebody who was helped someone i talk about so many women on this podcast
01:38:28.480who are just wholly abandoned and left to their own devices so i like to say if somebody if somebody
01:38:34.800was there for her and i would nominate frankly the gordon family i think her siblings her family
01:38:41.400her family and her siblings maybe also her cousin Agnes Keith because Agnes is she she's the wife of
01:38:50.340of James Stewart half-brother of Mary Queen of Scots which should make her an enemy but because
01:38:57.940she's related to Jean on Jean's mother's side she's kind of she kind of helps Jean but again
01:39:04.440that's Gordon family isn't it it's it's family so yeah I would say family yeah the Gordon Gordon
01:39:10.760siblings including Gordon siblings I'll say Gordon family including Agnes Keith just so that
01:39:16.080she's specifically noted Agnes Keith which hate to be counted as a Gordon Gordon family comma
01:39:21.700and Agnes Keith yes so just to all remember what story that relates to but yeah it was that's part
01:39:28.860of what makes this story as much as it involves so much crisis and drama and murder a nice story
01:46:21.760Most recently, I just added two new designs by Siobhan Gallagher, which are based on some
01:46:28.100just memorably bad reviews this podcast has gotten from people who just like don't get it but
01:46:33.880in this kind of poetic way I enjoy so one of them is a really cute design that says very biased
01:46:39.360which is what somebody called me and I own that and I am very biased and I think everybody is
01:46:46.340every historian is if you go all the way back to reading transcripts from Mary Queen of Scots this
01:46:51.320time lots of people are very biased for or against her it's not you can't tell history in an objective
01:46:57.120of way. Anyway, it's a really cute design. It's very biased. It's in this bubbly pink font. And
01:47:01.340then kind of as a companion in the sort of bubbly purple font, also designed by Siobhan Gallagher,
01:47:06.720it says rambling and unscholarly, which is what somebody called me in a review. And you know what,
01:47:12.700I'll own that as well. This podcast is not a textbook, although I do do a lot of research.
01:47:18.380Anyway, so you can get all that at our regular merch stores. And if you want to leave a nice
01:47:22.100review, you know, I can't say that I'm going to turn that into merch necessarily, but it could
01:47:26.700help counterbalance some of these other reviews. If you go to Apple podcasts, you can leave me a
01:47:31.560nice review if you want. You can also, there's a place if you're listening on Spotify, when you go
01:47:35.380into each episode, there's a place where you can leave nice comments too, or mean comments, you
01:47:39.320know, whatever moves you. You can also support this podcast by joining my Patreon, which is
01:47:44.620patreon.com slash Anne Foster writer, where if you pledge at least $1 a month, you get early ad free
01:47:50.860access to all the episodes. And then you also, if you pledge at least $5 or more a month, you get
01:47:55.480access to our special bonus podcasts. So that is So This Asshole, where I talk about men from
01:48:01.360history who are terrible. And I have pledged that if and when I get 500 people supporting me on0.96
01:48:08.660Patreon, I will do So This Asshole, John Knox. So, you know, if that persuades you. And then we also
01:48:14.780do Vulgar Peace theater episodes on the Patreon. That's where I'm joined by Alison Epstein and
01:48:20.320Lana Wood Johnson. And we talk about various costume dramas and just have a really good time.
01:48:24.240Most recently, we talked about The Woman King. The next one we have coming up is going to be about Ned Kelly, the Australian film starring Heath Ledger. We're also going to be talking about Chevalier, the movie about the Chevalier to St. George that just came out, which is a really good movie, although, you know, spoiler for that episode of the podcast.