Vulgar History - June 11, 2025


Women and Genderqueer People Who Ruled Over Africa

Topics
Trans History: The Lieutenant Nun Trans History: From Ancient Times to the Present Day

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Misogyny

16

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

40

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 Hello and welcome to Vulgar History, a feminist women's history comedy podcast. My name is 0.73
00:00:17.380 Anne Foster and today we are having a conversation with Paul Akpan, who is the author of a new
00:00:23.920 book that I have read and I super recommend that is called When We Ruled, The Rise and
00:00:28.540 fall of 12 African queens and warriors. And the cover of this book is the image of an African
00:00:35.820 leader who we've talked about on the show before. A couple of years ago, I did a season called
00:00:41.660 Internationale, where I was talking about people from various countries around the world. And one
00:00:46.160 of those people was Njinga of Mutamba and Ndongo, who is one of the figures covered in this book.
00:00:52.480 And I was so excited that Njinga was in this book. And Paula really has a great discussion
00:00:58.820 in the Njinga chapter about Njinga's gender identity, which is complex and interesting.
00:01:05.380 And the episodes that I did, I use she, her pronouns for Njinga. That was my choice. Paula
00:01:10.500 Akpan uses they, them pronouns, which I might argue is a better choice. And had I read this book
00:01:16.200 before I did those episodes, I probably would have made that choice as well. But if you want
00:01:19.560 to learn more about Njenga specifically, who is an incredibly interesting, audacious, and notable
00:01:28.300 person from history, you can listen back to The Vulgar History, two episodes. I think each episode
00:01:35.480 is at least an hour long talking about Njenga's story. I'll link to those in the show notes here,
00:01:40.420 or if you're on Spotify, I'll say this is like the, there's a thing on Spotify now where you can
00:01:44.240 say like related episodes. Anyway, so if you want to listen to that story, we do talk about Njenga,
00:01:48.580 but Paula explains the whole saga in this interview. You don't need to listen to those
00:01:52.860 first. And I was so excited to talk to Paula. Honestly, I had my whole schedule figured out
00:01:57.460 for episodes for this month. And then I heard about this book and I was like, stop the presses.
00:02:01.820 I need to do more episodes because I have to talk to Paula about this book.
00:02:05.860 So who is she? Paula Apkin is a historian and journalist with a BA in sociology and an MA in
00:02:11.620 Black British history. This is her first nonfiction book. It's so good. It's so interesting.
00:02:18.240 we talk about all the reasons why in this chat. And it's Pride Month here in North America. So I
00:02:24.020 was especially excited to talk to Paula about the queer African history that she gets into in this
00:02:30.080 book as well. You'll note that the subtitle is The Rise and Fall of Twelve African Queens and
00:02:35.720 Warriors. That's because not everybody in this book is a queen. Not everybody in this book would
00:02:41.420 use that term. So it's like queens and also genderqueer leaders. And anyway, Paula is so 0.80
00:02:48.520 fun to talk to you. And I hope you really enjoy this conversation with Paula Akpan about her new
00:02:52.800 book, When We Ruled. So I'm joined today by Paula Akpan, author of When We Ruled, The Rise and Fall
00:03:05.640 of 12 African queens and warriors.
00:03:08.620 Welcome, Paula.
00:03:09.780 Hi, thank you so much for having me.
00:03:12.360 I'm so excited to talk to you about this book.
00:03:14.840 I'm so excited that this book exists, first of all.
00:03:17.940 Can you tell everybody kind of the scope
00:03:19.960 of what this book comprises, like the time periods,
00:03:23.560 like what kind of people you're talking about?
00:03:26.220 Absolutely.
00:03:27.300 So the book covers around about the last thousand years,
00:03:32.020 but we can start it around the 12th century.
00:03:35.640 And it follows 12 women rulers, but also genderqueer rulers across the breadth of the African continent.
00:03:45.420 And I specifically wanted to examine below the Sahara Desert as well, because so much of what we think about when it comes to African civilizations tends to be focused in northern Africa and around Egypt.
00:03:59.320 and i think it fuels this idea of an underdeveloped or barren africa so i really
00:04:06.740 wanted to explore from ethiopia to burundi angola madagascar and all of these figures who are
00:04:16.760 elites they aren't representative of the conditions of african women during these periods from the 0.74
00:04:23.640 past century through to the 21st century but also the power that they wielded um whether
00:04:31.260 fighting against european imperialist forces or leveraging that power against their own people
00:04:39.800 to pretty detrimental means um so i'd say it's i say it's that yeah yeah no and i love that
00:04:47.280 and i mean like you said there's women and also genderqueer people so that's where the title is
00:04:52.460 African queens and warriors so it's expansive it encompasses different kinds of leaders
00:04:58.220 exactly I I was I wanted to reflect the fact that in Jingo who is also on the front of the book
00:05:06.060 how they understood their gender with plurality they didn't have gendered pronouns in their
00:05:13.120 language of Kimbundu so I just I wanted to at least acknowledge that um somewhat and we're
00:05:20.380 gonna get into that we're gonna get into the gender stuff oh my god there's like y'all there's
00:05:26.720 a lot of gay stuff in this book and it's really exciting but first I just want to just like so
00:05:30.280 everybody understands the book a bit better so how did you how many of these people had you heard of
00:05:35.240 before you began the process for writing this book like all of them or some of them or how did
00:05:39.240 you choose which 12 would be the 12 yeah so I knew of a few of them a lot of so I'm half Nigerian
00:05:46.300 and a lot of west africans will know of nana ya santwa this um elderly figure who took on the
00:05:54.880 british at the dawn of the 20th century and so there are these figures that some of us will know
00:06:02.860 by virtue of what our heritage is um but many of them i hadn't encountered in depth like i knew
00:06:10.480 about njinga i knew about poku um but in no depth or they came to me as as like pedagogical kind of
00:06:20.420 tools um the likes of poku and moremi who um who was a ruler in present-day nigeria they are found
00:06:31.020 in children's books and you know these selfless figures who gave up um who made personal sacrifices
00:06:39.500 for kin and kingdom and I wanted to just dig a little bit deeper examine a bit more but crucially
00:06:48.320 as an African of the diaspora I wanted it to be led by local storytellers local historians
00:06:56.440 visits to heritage sites so that kind of formed a bit of the selection process I created a history
00:07:04.140 nerd that I am create like a massive matrix with as many rulers that I could find that were women
00:07:11.860 or genderqueer um across the continent and then kind of narrowed it down on other heritage sites
00:07:18.640 still standing are there storytellers that I can locate and historians that I can locate who would
00:07:24.120 be willing to engage with me and those that kind of shaped like that was one of the parameters
00:07:31.160 obviously the um northern africa um you know thoughts as well shapes that and just i think
00:07:39.780 also how much source material was kind of accessible to me especially as someone who
00:07:44.600 is an english speaker which of course again shapes so much of the book because you will
00:07:51.160 have archival materials for example in madagascar but they are in french or malagasy so that was
00:07:58.700 kind of a sticking point when i was trying to research run of the luna but then being able to
00:08:04.420 locate english-speaking storytellers which again skews the history that i'm i'm kind of pulling
00:08:09.680 together so i think that is that is something that historians especially engaging histories that are
00:08:17.440 in indigenous tongues or other languages um how we're mediating all of this through language i
00:08:24.680 think language comes up a lot across the book as it should but those were a couple of the factors
00:08:30.060 and also if I would be able to actually have any access so for example Sudan and you know
00:08:39.460 South Sudan those were places that I was just I'm not sure that I can actually safely access and
00:08:45.960 it's why I didn't end up traveling to Ethiopia even though I knew that I wanted to study
00:08:51.320 and write about Minto up.
00:08:54.060 So those are a bit of a few of the factors.
00:08:57.200 Well, and you mentioned this,
00:08:58.240 and I think everybody should know
00:08:59.240 that part of what was really interesting to me,
00:09:02.120 I mean, everything was interesting to me about the book,
00:09:03.820 but I'm like, oh, I've never read a book like this.
00:09:05.320 Like you're inserted in the narrative,
00:09:07.280 talking about the places that you went
00:09:08.560 and the people that you talked to.
00:09:09.840 Can you describe sort of that,
00:09:11.780 your decision to travel to these places
00:09:13.420 and to insert yourself in the book?
00:09:15.000 Of course.
00:09:16.600 So traveling was just from the start,
00:09:21.320 was a non-negotiable um it's part of my historical practice but also that to not travel and attempt
00:09:29.860 to write this book from london going to i don't know so as university and sitting in those archives
00:09:36.440 it reeks of the kind of colonial anthropology work that would take place across the periods
00:09:44.520 that i'm examining where you'd have british uh explorers and expeditioners she's you're making
00:09:53.160 words write about lands that they had never actually stepped foot in and would perhaps
00:10:07.780 visit after the fact so there's one of the writers who is quite fundamental to what we
00:10:14.020 know of Rana Faluna, that ruler of the Imarena kingdom found in present-day Madagascar,
00:10:20.720 he wrote an entire history of Madagascar without visiting the kingdom. And I don't want to repeat
00:10:28.900 that. I don't want to suggest that African history work is a discipline that doesn't require
00:10:37.080 the same rigor that we would expect if you were doing classical history work. You would surely
00:10:43.100 go to visit all of the sites that are toted as classical history sites so um that was quite
00:10:51.280 crucial for me and in terms of inserting myself I guess I really wanted from the start I really
00:11:02.620 wanted to ensure that not only was I exploring the legacies of these figures but also the impact
00:11:09.520 that their rules have had on these present-day countries today and the descendants of you know
00:11:18.000 the people that they ruled over who live with these legacies how do Madagascan people sorry
00:11:26.320 Malagasy people um understand Rana Valuna who is remembered particularly by colonial historians as
00:11:35.280 the Bloody Mary of Madagascar and slaughtered so many, tortured so many within her kingdom 0.61
00:11:44.660 as a means of trying to defend it against Christianity and defend it against Western 0.88
00:11:51.300 imperial overtures. How do they understand Rana Valuna's legacy today? And the fact that,
00:12:01.780 you know, Madagascar was colonized by the French in the end anyway, despite Rana Valuna's efforts.
00:12:09.840 So I felt that so many of the conversations that I was having were very revealing and very
00:12:17.900 generative as well, because I am coming into this space as an African of the diaspora. So I do think
00:12:27.240 that there is when I was having conversations with people there was almost like especially if
00:12:33.420 people were queer as well a kind of community or link a connection that was kind of fostered
00:12:40.040 and allowed people to kind of try and unravel some of their difficulties around these figures
00:12:46.740 beyond the official narratives beyond government narratives some people having skepticism around
00:12:53.440 some of the figures that I've included in the book that are upheld as you know nationalistic
00:13:00.240 kind of symbols for liberation for uprising but actually privately having some some questions
00:13:08.460 people trying to work out their feelings around rulers that they herald who were fundamental to
00:13:15.860 the um shuttling of abducted africans across the continent and through to the americas and i think
00:13:25.100 that those kind of conversations really they were so eye-opening and i think very revealing about
00:13:34.540 the figures in questions and how in the figures in question and how they're perceived today so
00:13:39.780 i just i felt like it was quite crucial but also i'm a journalist as well and i am not interested
00:13:47.620 in like the myths of objectivity i i think i tried to make an argument across the book that
00:13:55.780 western historical practice is often just as speculative is often just as um subjective but
00:14:06.700 is presented as a neutral base for where all other history work should originate from.
00:14:14.100 When you have instances littered across the book of colonial historians conferring with
00:14:21.300 one another, trying to make juicier details because they know that this is what will appeal
00:14:26.740 to their readership back in the UK.
00:14:29.720 You have the fact that some of them would never talk about the defeats of their colonial
00:14:35.840 forces and really emphasize their victories there's so much that has been augmented in terms
00:14:43.440 of western history production and i wanted to actually lean into the understanding that
00:14:50.780 the archive is also a site of violence and when you have abducted africans who are described as
00:15:00.440 you know listed as cargo but not as valuable as gold or mahogany and but this is the only way
00:15:06.860 that we understand their existence their presence that they they lived then that is also a violence
00:15:14.480 and i guess searching for counter histories that grapple with the um the colonial agendas that
00:15:25.920 underpin so much of what we know of the African continent that was crucial to me and I really
00:15:32.460 leaned into I tried to lean into my subjectivity and also account for the fact that I am an outsider
00:15:41.720 that the real experts are the people that I spoke to those are the conversations that hold all of
00:15:47.480 the gems and I didn't want to bastardize their words I wanted to kind of present our conversations
00:15:53.680 and exchanges as they were so that's a really long answer to quite a simple question
00:15:59.620 no and I think all the nuance is really good for people to understand who haven't read your book
00:16:05.740 yet just to know that like you're there in the book and you're throughout like you're
00:16:09.320 interrogating these questions like you said about well and I appreciate this as well in in your book
00:16:14.380 that the the figures are all given the respect of looking at the nuance of their life like not just
00:16:20.360 a hero not just a villain but all all the different sides to present them as like a full-fledged
00:16:25.060 person but you mentioned the the way that some of these records were colonial based with their 0.90
00:16:30.740 biases and their understanding and that gets us into all the queer stuff in your book which I
00:16:35.160 love to talk about especially because it's pride month so can we start with Njinga and absolutely
00:16:43.440 pronouns and gender absolutely so njinga is such a fascinating figure who is widely
00:16:53.840 presented as a queen as a woman um which again really bolsters nationalistic um symbolism
00:17:04.080 and especially when um in 1960 that was the year of africa and you had all of these present-day
00:17:12.380 countries emerging and becoming independent. They wanted to bolster this kind of pan-Africanist
00:17:19.320 fervor with, you know, these historical figures who have risen up against these colonial forces
00:17:25.020 before, which means that we can do it again. And so Njinga was quite perfect for that, defying 0.84
00:17:31.160 13 Portuguese governors who were trying to squeeze the kingdoms of Ndongo and Matamba, 0.81
00:17:39.640 which are found in present-day Angola um across her reign so her reign their reign this is the
00:17:46.680 problem um so even then right I have this is the thing around the pronouns because the English
00:17:55.700 language it it imbues so much meaning into words that didn't exist in the lot of the languages of
00:18:06.120 these African societies. So N'Jinga's language of Kimbundu, it didn't have any gendered pronouns.
00:18:13.280 And therefore, to describe them as she, her, it, I think, ushers in a perceived notion of what that
00:18:23.840 person should look like, how they should engage, what that behaviour looks like. Meanwhile, N'Jinga 0.96
00:18:29.060 often wanted to be referred to by a male coded name wore masculine clothing sought to be
00:18:37.900 understood on parity with their portuguese counterparts which was really confusing to the
00:18:45.060 people well to the occupiers to the portuguese occupiers because they had an understanding of
00:18:50.300 a queen of a donna um and it wasn't just in jinga as well um within their court they had
00:19:00.040 people who we would describe today as assigned um male at birth but lived their lives out as
00:19:09.440 women were understood as grandmother they were called kim banders and they were believed to have
00:19:17.300 a very special power there was an honor for any man to be married to kianbanda and i think
00:19:27.320 particularly exploring in jinga and also the ogodje who are the all women fighting regiment
00:19:34.860 um of the ancient kingdom of dahomey and were a lot of historians they almost have question marks
00:19:43.480 about whether they could have ever been sexually active with each other even though there is
00:19:49.720 evidence that they were and they colonial historians have described it in retrospect as
00:19:56.980 these Dahomeans trying to follow through their concept of duality which runs throughout their
00:20:04.660 belief systems of one thing must always be matched by another that if people outside of the palace 0.99
00:20:11.040 were having sex with women sex workers and other women then of course I guess Leogogier maybe did
00:20:18.680 the same thing but it was carried out through to its logical extreme. So here you see a lot of 0.92
00:20:25.120 historians imbuing their work with their own biases, with their own conditions of heteronormativity
00:20:32.900 and unable to actually explore the expansiveness that we know is inherent in queerness that we
00:20:41.840 know is inherent within sexual expression gender expression and in jingas gender plurality
00:20:50.580 is understood perhaps as a costume perhaps as a way to accrue more respect by putting on
00:20:58.520 a facade of a man whereas the godier it's you know this is just character to its logical extreme
00:21:06.060 there's no other reason why these soldiers would want to have sex with other women or with each 0.99
00:21:12.360 other and i think the virtue of being a black lesbian woman means that i enter these spaces 0.96
00:21:20.040 as a historian you know these as living testament these are not uh beyond the realm of possibility
00:21:27.900 Whereas they are, there's so much question and doubt and really underpinned by this understanding that homosexuality, queerness, transness is new, is recent and didn't originate or exist in African societies,
00:21:53.600 especially predating contact with colonial forces and it's I felt like it was so critical to
00:22:03.800 include not only these figures and these like histories that predate the terms queer and trans
00:22:12.820 but we would understand them as such today but also little other examples about the Sangomas
00:22:18.500 of um zulu societies found in south africa who marry people of any gender um the besotho women
00:22:28.580 who are found in present day lesotho who have always had long-standing relationships between
00:22:35.140 women and that is just the the state of play that is their cultural um that's performed part of their
00:22:42.300 cultural beliefs i've really wanted to include it because they're i think a lot of black africans
00:22:49.720 and queer africans will no doubt have encountered the understanding that queerness and sexuality
00:22:59.440 lesbianism staff street all of it is some sort of western import is some sort of white import into
00:23:06.200 our previously very religious christian um societies and which allows so much myth but
00:23:15.120 like an externalism of queerness which has always existed within african societies so it was really
00:23:24.120 crucial for me to include it but also i hope that you know maybe people will be drawn to the book by
00:23:31.180 this idea of queens and um you know these elite figures because they want an exploration of
00:23:41.360 african histories that don't hinge on enslavement and trauma and unimaginable unimaginable
00:23:50.240 suffering and so kind of turn towards pictures of wealth but so they're drawn to the book hopefully
00:23:58.160 and then i've just slipped in some queer theory there and just slipped in you know a reckoning
00:24:04.840 with um christianity a reckoning with um transness and hopefully just pulling people into
00:24:16.480 wider areas of discourse that they didn't expect when initially picking up the book um so yeah
00:24:25.860 it reminds me um of just some what a lot of recent scholars are doing now talking about
00:24:32.480 indigenous cultures in north america for instance and talking about like the the damage that
00:24:39.520 colonialism did everywhere is expansive and multifaceted and part of that was kind of coming
00:24:46.240 to a place and seeing something that they didn't that wasn't their experience it's like oh this
00:24:50.760 person is wearing a dress and to me that looks like a man and that must mean that these are 0.96
00:24:54.780 backwards people that this must mean this has to be fixed or changed instead of understanding what 0.99
00:24:59.740 the culture was and so a lot of like the work like you're doing in here is kind of explaining well
00:25:03.680 here's what it was like before here's what they might have seen and it was misinterpreted and
00:25:08.240 here's what it actually was and that leads to so many i mean i'm really happy to be talking to you
00:25:13.600 about this in pride month because all the discussion about like oh there's all these
00:25:17.920 trans people and there didn't used to be it's like no there always was and then colonialism
00:25:22.420 stamped it out. And now it's coming back to how it maybe was. It's not a new invention. And I 0.93
00:25:30.580 think it's so great that you have these concrete, specific examples of cultures where this was
00:25:35.120 happening, where same-sex relationships were happening. And it's not new. It's actually very
00:25:40.360 old. And yeah, so I was just so happy that that was part of your book. And now for a quick
00:25:45.280 advertising break.
00:25:48.120 Hungry now.
00:25:51.340 Now?
00:25:53.520 What about now?
00:25:55.760 Whenever it hits you,
00:25:57.400 wherever you are, grab an
00:25:59.280 O'Henry bar to satisfy
00:26:01.180 your hunger. With its delicious
00:26:03.480 combination of big, crunchy, salty
00:26:05.580 peanuts covered in creamy caramel
00:26:07.480 and chewy fudge with a
00:26:09.580 chocolatey coating. Swing by a
00:26:11.500 gas station and get an O'Henry today.
00:26:13.620 Welcome to the realms of peril and glory.
00:26:22.660 Explore the mechanically magical vistas of Vale,
00:26:26.120 the paranormal mysteries of liminal London,
00:26:30.420 and the cyberpunk chaos of Cyborg.
00:26:35.280 Be awed by our incredible guests from familiar shows like Oxventure and No Rolls Barred.
00:26:42.520 Search Realms of Peril and Glory to find out more
00:26:46.680 The war is over and both sides lost
00:26:53.720 Kingdoms were reduced to cinders
00:26:55.780 An army scattered like bones in the dust
00:26:58.940 Now the survivors claw to what's left of a broken world
00:27:03.420 Praying the darkness chooses someone else tonight
00:27:06.420 But in the shadow dark, the darkness always wins
00:27:10.560 this is old school adventuring
00:27:13.000 at it's most cruel
00:27:14.340 your torch ticks down in real time
00:27:16.780 and when that flame dies
00:27:18.140 something else rises to finish the job
00:27:20.440 this is a brutal rules light nightmare
00:27:22.720 with a story that emerges organically
00:27:25.420 based on the decisions that the characters make
00:27:28.020 this is what it felt like to play RPGs in the 80s
00:27:30.460 and man, it is so good to be back
00:27:32.740 join the Glass Cannon podcast
00:27:34.060 as we plunge into the shadow dark
00:27:35.820 every Thursday night at 8pm Eastern
00:27:37.860 on youtube.com slash the glass cannon
00:27:40.160 with the podcast version dropping the next day.
00:27:43.520 See what everybody's talking about
00:27:44.840 and join us in the dark.
00:27:51.500 I'm Anne Foster,
00:27:52.700 and I have never watched the show
00:27:54.040 Spartacus, Blood, and Sand.
00:27:55.760 And I'm Gina Berry,
00:27:56.840 and I've watched this show numerous times.
00:27:59.780 On our new podcast, NeferTV,
00:28:01.540 we discuss TV shows and movies
00:28:03.060 set in ancient history.
00:28:04.440 This season, we are discussing
00:28:05.620 Spartacus, Blood, and Sand.
00:28:08.500 Follow NeferTV.
00:28:10.160 That's N-E-F-E-R-T-V, wherever you get your podcasts.
00:28:16.960 And we're back.
00:28:18.960 Yay, I'm so glad as well.
00:28:21.200 And I guess this is, I think this is such an interesting part of like publishing as an industry, right, as well.
00:28:29.160 Because I think that they want sometimes a very specific and like categorized idea of what you're working on, what kind of work you're producing.
00:28:39.540 and okay this is an african history book but i really hope that it kind of pushes a bit at the
00:28:49.240 genre in terms of actually this is feminism this is politics this is queer theory this is
00:28:56.820 so much um that i guess when we're talking about pride month as well i i would be really intrigued
00:29:05.280 if my book gets included in conversations around queerness around pride because i think that that
00:29:12.460 there are still narratives that we're troubling but african history means that it stands in silo
00:29:17.740 away from queer history away from trans histories and like you said that they are not only are they
00:29:25.520 intertwined they have predated the terms they have existed long before you know missionaries
00:29:32.840 started bringing over their families and their nuclear family setups to try and demonstrate
00:29:38.640 to indigenous populations that this is actually how you should be living your life you seem to 0.94
00:29:44.120 have no established mother or father within the family okay that can't work a whole community 0.57
00:29:50.840 cannot mother or parent a child it actually has to look very individualized this is you know you
00:29:57.120 have your own homestead you have your own yeah so then kind of um re-instituting these 0.91
00:30:05.300 heteronormative values while at the same time ridding um indigenous populations of
00:30:12.260 their places of worship and commemoration their shrines so though i would say that
00:30:19.000 um the bringing in of nuclear families to kind of diminish not only queerness but also
00:30:28.320 kinship ties this was part of a huge western um strategy to uh supplant to replace to 0.85
00:30:41.160 demonize and point people towards actually this is how you should be living
00:30:47.040 while completely misunderstanding and recklessly and carelessly just displacing everything that
00:30:58.440 had come before so this is also when we're talking about for example queens um in english we we queen
00:31:07.280 can actually stand in for so much what kind of queen are we talking about are we talking about
00:31:12.620 someone who is a queen consort a queen it gets used um to describe so much whereas we're trying
00:31:22.700 to fix that language to african elite figures where queen might be better replaced with high
00:31:31.300 priestess queen might be better replaced with you know some sort of divine figure so alongside
00:31:38.200 besides distorting all of their familial uh social relational practices also distorting 0.95
00:31:47.240 complete like their understandings of rule sovereignty um and the ways that their societies
00:31:55.380 were functioning um and honestly it's still depressing it's it's a because i'm and i
00:32:03.440 i sometimes think about my conclusion i'm just like maybe i should have things on your lighter
00:32:10.020 note but i guess i i was i was being really real in how um how devastating it is to see the wealth
00:32:21.880 of cultural systems beliefs um ways of living that were
00:32:30.980 disbanded stamped out demonized and like historians like myself historians in those
00:32:42.620 present-day countries are doing what they can to preserve uh snatch it all of the little glimpses
00:32:48.940 that they see because it wasn't deemed to be in line with european western ideas of civilization
00:32:57.680 um and as white superior um societies it was their job their duty to impose their beliefs on 0.84
00:33:10.720 the barbaric African societies that they sought out um yeah it's it's it's difficult and I think
00:33:22.060 especially when you're maybe dealing with um histories that are so close to your identities 1.00
00:33:26.800 in some ways as well um but I at least hope with pulling together a couple of these African
00:33:35.360 histories that it just gives people a starting point um a a way of challenging western history
00:33:43.020 production just saying okay actually if you can bend and augment what this history looked like
00:33:50.760 here then where else have you done that and to kind of search outwardly from that point
00:33:57.120 well and also just in terms of the the way that the records the the colonial writing about these
00:34:05.100 people was partially, you know, propaganda to explain. It's like, and this is why it was
00:34:10.260 important that the British or the Dutch or the Portuguese came in and changed everything because 1.00
00:34:14.740 look at how horrifying it was before. I'm using air quotes, listeners. But I mean, that really 0.99
00:34:21.480 comes out of the story of like Rana Valuna, for instance, who is still, like you're talking about
00:34:27.820 the people we're talking to there, like she was so demonized at the time that even people in that
00:34:32.160 country still are just like oh she was a bad queen I think somebody called her who you talked to can
00:34:36.300 you talk about her like that complicated legacy and how how that came to be absolutely so Rana
00:34:44.200 Valuna is a 19th century ruler um ruled over in Marina and in present-day Madagascar and
00:34:52.080 she followed through with what her husband started her husband Radama wanted the island to become 0.77
00:35:00.740 an island state that rivaled the british that rivaled the french and to follow codes of
00:35:07.000 self-sufficiency to have minimal contact with other nations and to truly rule themselves
00:35:14.240 and part of the threat to that was christianity you had these christian missionaries that were
00:35:22.680 beginning to convert Marina peoples and Rana Valuna took that as not even kind of like a
00:35:34.640 political issue but also an issue of like war and sovereignty because with the Marina people
00:35:41.740 it was understanding their ruler as a divine figure who also channels the will of the ancestors
00:35:50.660 So to follow Jesus, for example, is to not only take on a new set of beliefs, but to completely sperm your ancestral beliefs as well.
00:36:02.080 And so Rana Valuna took to torturing, to killing, hunting down converts and missionaries across the island.
00:36:15.420 and when the british because you had like these um british colonial kind of dwellers
00:36:25.780 representatives who were attempting to make a life on the island when rana valuna was turning
00:36:33.260 her wrath towards them expecting them to either carry out the work that would normally be reserved
00:36:39.220 for enslaved people or to simply vacate the island if they weren't willing to do that
00:36:44.820 Then the British, the French, this was such an affront to their power. They wanted to, the same way that the British had hold of the island of Mauritius, they wanted to repeat the same thing for themselves as well, because it would aid their trading routes. 0.51
00:37:04.480 And here was this brown woman, this vigorously kind of determined woman who wanted nothing to do with them, who was actually spurning the overtures of, you know, these Christian powers who were only trying to expand their wealth, their knowledge to these uncivilized savages, right? 0.76
00:37:32.240 So they began to, in their home countries, particularly in British, a lot of propaganda, a lot of very anti-Ranovaluna, anti kind of the Malagasy kind of peoples. 0.77
00:37:50.640 but at the same time they had princess victoria who was coming through so their criticism couldn't
00:37:58.380 rest on the fact that ranvaluna was a woman but rather that she was unsaved uncivilized 1.00
00:38:04.640 she was a malay jezebel she was brown with smallpox marks all over her face compared to 0.98
00:38:11.840 the pristine white womanhood of this fair queen this white queen coming through 0.93
00:38:19.260 um so this very much has shaped the legacy of rana valuna and how she earned you know titles
00:38:28.320 like the bloody mary of madagasta these very there was a binary that had to be constructed
00:38:34.220 between Rana Valuna and Victoria and this also is coupled with the very incredibly brutal
00:38:44.920 violent acts like she halved essentially her population like across her reign and
00:38:52.800 there was so much violence wrapped up in what she did and what a number of the figures in the book 0.98
00:39:01.020 and Jenga was critical to the funnelling of enslaved Africans through their kingdoms.
00:39:08.480 And unfortunately for us, our understanding of their cruelty is so hampered,
00:39:17.440 is so garbled by the determined agendas of the Western and colonial chroniclers
00:39:25.460 who were um divvying up their lives who were at the same time trying to make their rules and
00:39:34.340 reigns really lurid to really jump off the page and grab the british public the british reading
00:39:39.980 public who were encountering these um tales of tropical islands where there are lemurs and
00:39:47.800 monkeys running free that are you know dominated by the established people like this was there was
00:39:54.420 also a duty on the part of these writers to conjure up really fantastical imagery that
00:40:01.320 suited the readership, that bolstered their understanding of their own white superiority
00:40:06.420 and why they believed that they were in a position to redeem, to save, to deliver
00:40:15.440 um societies like the marina peoples um and of course this there is no shortage of understanding
00:40:27.700 the depravity of a lot of rana voluna's actions um but it's also that her role is often presented
00:40:35.940 as a silo she was just you know just a mad queen rather than examining the the context the
00:40:45.020 conditions, what she was reacting to, the fact that she was continuing her husband's legacy. 1.00
00:40:50.500 A lot of the things that he had put in place were blamed on Raina Valluna. And so it was framed as
00:40:57.480 this madwoman who had come in and disrupted what her, you know, honourable husband had been 0.84
00:41:06.140 starting. He had understood that he needed the British and the French. This wasn't true. He, 0.92
00:41:11.400 you know he was for isolationism but again so there is misogyny there is racist and um 0.99
00:41:21.220 oh the the word has literally floated out of my head but I use it all the time anyway eugenics 0.75
00:41:29.900 yes oh thank god um the yeah the myths of white superiority that they all underpin how 0.77
00:41:38.760 rana voluna has been historicized and is understood on the madagascan island today
00:41:47.100 um and how we read her as well so i've wanted to kind of trouble our understanding of these
00:41:54.820 figures who you know are presented as villains um or as simply heroes and actually that it does
00:42:05.640 none of us a it's a disservice to all of us um to look at people with such a reductive and
00:42:15.180 lacking nuance kind of a way and that was a terrible way of wording that um
00:42:22.400 but yeah I guess that's that's kind of the legacy of run of luna which is
00:42:27.860 really complicated it means that like you said some people understand her is a really bad queen
00:42:33.320 other people that I spoke to understood her as some sort of feminist figure who was taking a
00:42:38.760 stand against anti-imperialism and it's it's so loaded it's so complicated and when I think about
00:42:45.960 Madagascar I'm I just I really wish that I could find out you know just how Rana Voluna I would
00:42:54.340 understand the history of Madagascar since she died um the way that her son unraveled basically
00:43:03.220 all of her life's work the way that Madagascar was colonized by the French anyway the legacies
00:43:09.540 that you see across the island today like I noticed how many um when I was at my hotel and 1.00
00:43:16.840 I ended up asking someone about this but just you'd see a lot of young Malagasy women with 0.72
00:43:22.300 white older men and I was seeing this every night constantly and this is also part of the legacies
00:43:28.920 because um there is such a good standard of living for uh westerners in madagascar particularly if you
00:43:38.900 are a french person you speak french um there has been an encouragement over like the last decade or
00:43:45.820 two for older white french men to you know build a life in madagascar where you have a cheap standard 0.56
00:43:55.220 of living you have you know malagasy women who there is there are a lot of sex workers but then 0.85
00:44:02.380 there's also this assumption that every malagasy woman is just up for it because you swan in with
00:44:08.460 all of this money um this is a colonial legacy and it's it's permeates the island today um so it's
00:44:18.580 There is so much that's loaded in Rana Valuna's story, but also why I wanted to also focus on the contemporary, because you cannot separate the Madagascan island today from its past as an Imerina kingdom heralded, led by Rana Valuna.
00:44:39.060 Yeah. And I think, too, I come across this just in my work as well. And just a lot of time when you see a woman leader, a genderqueer leader anywhere in history who was in any way brutal, who was in any way a military success.
00:44:56.900 And then it's sort of like, oh, wow, this person, like this is, look at all these things. 0.83
00:45:00.520 Renaud Lovune is such a good example of this.
00:45:02.680 Or Njinga, if you look at them, it's like, but what were they up against?
00:45:06.160 What were their enemies doing?
00:45:07.840 It's like, you need to put it, and your book does this really well, I think,
00:45:10.380 of putting it in the context of like, yeah, like they did,
00:45:12.440 these were the brutal acts that they seem to have perpetuated. 0.59
00:45:15.100 And these were the brutal acts that the British were doing, 0.81
00:45:17.460 that the Portuguese were doing, that the Dutch were doing.
00:45:19.220 It's not, it's not just like everything was chill. 0.97
00:45:21.620 And suddenly this mad woman came in and started killing everybody.
00:45:24.280 It's like, it was a reaction to what was happening. And we celebrate that in some like, I don't know, Boudicca in England, you know, fighting against the Romans. It's like, hell yeah, look at this woman. It's not just like, oh, she killed all these people. It's like, that was great because that was a white woman. And because it's sort of like a history of like the, I forget if she was Anglo-Saxon, but like, you know, of like kicking the Romans out of England. That's like a success story. 0.93
00:45:48.740 So like in that context, we can celebrate her. But in these contexts, it's like if you remove the context, yeah, Rana Lavuna seems like a madwoman. But it's like, no, this is what she was fighting. And she knew this is what happened to other places. And this is why she was so determined about it. 0.87
00:46:02.880 Absolutely. And also these systems already demonized her, criminalized her for rejecting European imperialism, for, you know, being a brown person who decided that she didn't want to engage these European powers who were intent on her kingdom and the resources of her land.
00:46:25.240 So we're not even able, I think, very, well, I tried, but it's very difficult to appraise her cruelty without having to, okay, let me say that again. 0.57
00:46:44.740 It's very difficult to appraise her cruelty because it's been so obfuscated by the fact that she was a brown woman that needed to be taken down, that she was an African that needed to be taken down because of the nerve in the first place for rejecting Christianity, for rejecting European ideals. 0.89
00:47:02.220 so when you're already starting from that base level that completely changes like you said like 0.89
00:47:08.500 the playing field it's it's not like they were on equal footing and then suddenly you know
00:47:14.160 rana valuna started chopping people in half like that's not how it played out but of course
00:47:19.540 so much of that has been removed from the official narratives that have emerged out of
00:47:25.960 you know British history production and I guess this is why it's so critical for
00:47:33.760 increasingly more historians more scholars to be working from a completely in my opinion
00:47:42.700 a critical understanding of the colonial archive and its legacies and how we go about
00:47:51.500 disassembling those myths while trying to locate these figures locate the acts that they did
00:47:58.400 whether those were you know good um and contributed to the success of their lands and the success of
00:48:06.820 their peoples or whether they were brutal and harmful um but it requires us to do the very
00:48:14.080 best we can not to repeat colonial myth. Well, thank you so much for talking to me today. And
00:48:21.540 thank you so much for writing this book. I was so excited, like just on a personal note. So I do
00:48:26.280 this podcast where I talk about women from history. And a few years ago, I was making a conscious
00:48:30.320 effort to try to talk about not just people from England, France, Spain, because there's so many
00:48:36.240 books about those people already. So for me as an English speaker, it's like, well, that's who I'm
00:48:40.320 able to research. I'm like, no, I want to learn about other people. I want to learn about the
00:48:43.800 Queens of Africa. And it's just like, Jenga was kind of it. I was like, that's the only person
00:48:49.060 I could find enough information about that I could do a podcast about it. So I was like,
00:48:53.840 this book exists. This is amazing. You're introducing me to so many people I hadn't
00:48:57.280 heard of. So just like personally, I'm just like, oh, I'm excited to have new people to
00:49:00.760 know about and to maybe get to explore more deeply. So I appreciate that very much as a
00:49:05.600 podcaster. You are welcome. Thank you for reading.
00:49:09.900 and you're going to be doing you are doing so many events this episode is airing towards the
00:49:15.840 beginning of june if people want to keep up with all the many appearances that you're going to be
00:49:19.840 doing you have a website the lists where you're going to be and when right yes i do just paul
00:49:24.860 appan.com i'm honestly just paul appan on everything apart from uh twitter formerly
00:49:30.680 known as x because i got rid of that didn't i um but yeah i'm just about i normally update my
00:49:37.540 instagram the most and of course my website yeah well thank you so much for talking with me today
00:49:42.840 about this book and i hope that you continue to have great success talking to to people about it
00:49:48.780 as people are able to read it actually i have one more question which is what has the response been
00:49:53.460 like to people who have read it like now that you're out in the world talking about it with
00:49:56.660 people it has honestly been like really um humbling in a lot of ways especially when i'm talking to
00:50:05.360 older africans um who just talk about how they've been looking for like 20 years for something
00:50:15.020 around this topic and specifically with the focus on african women rulers but i'm obviously
00:50:22.620 throwing in genderqueer rulers because you will learn at any age um and just like how powerful
00:50:30.920 it is to see it in the kind of mainstream kind of space to be able to go into a waterstones and
00:50:40.200 see a book about 12 african women and genderqueer rulers just staring out at you so that's been
00:50:47.080 incredible um and i think what's touched me most is just people who are from the communities and
00:50:55.000 peoples like the ethnic groups that are mentioned within the book um and I guess just feeling like
00:51:02.480 they have a greater connection um with their community as a result with their identity as a
00:51:09.340 result so that has been incredible but of course they've also been because of my stance on
00:51:16.980 challenging um western history production and the archive and searching counter histories
00:51:25.120 then people who may be very um beholden to institutions and academic institutions
00:51:34.800 questioning you know objectivity and well how can you critique like western scholars in this way
00:51:43.600 involved but um which I always expected um but I think because I always knew I always knew who I
00:51:52.600 was writing this for or had in mind I was thinking of Africans on the continent and on the and within
00:52:00.020 the diaspora and that has been my sole kind of focus and that is the only way that I know how
00:52:08.440 to engage these different modes of storytelling that come pop up across the book whether it's you
00:52:14.940 know dance or praise poems or whatever it is um i i i feel i hope that i have done them proud
00:52:25.820 um and yeah from the response like it's there's there's been excitement um so that's nice and
00:52:35.040 And yeah, more of that, I hope.
00:52:39.160 That's wonderful.
00:52:40.040 Thank you so much.
00:52:40.880 That's what I hope for you as well.
00:52:42.140 More of that.
00:52:42.940 More of that.
00:52:43.760 Thank you so much for having me.
00:52:45.560 Yeah, thank you so much.
00:52:50.860 So as Paula said, you can keep up with her and what she's up to on Instagram, where she's
00:52:54.460 at Paula Akpan, or her website is PaulaAkpan.com.
00:52:57.400 She's got a bunch of appearances coming up across the UK.
00:53:01.660 And yeah, she's such a fun person.
00:53:04.120 And I was so excited to talk to her.
00:53:05.500 I read this book and I was just like, every page, just so much looking forward to talking
00:53:09.900 to her about everything.
00:53:10.860 When I read books for interviews, I go through and I take pictures of the pages with like
00:53:15.200 specific things that interest me or that I want to remember so I can bring up in the
00:53:18.280 interview.
00:53:18.720 And I had so many pictures taken of various things she talks about in this book.
00:53:22.220 So again, the book is available in the UK and Commonwealth territories, as well as in
00:53:26.760 Canada and the US.
00:53:27.700 And it is called When We Ruled, The Rise and Fall of 12 African Queens and Warriors.
00:53:32.080 it's a book that I'm going to keep on hand just for myself for future episode idea purposes but
00:53:37.440 I do think it's a good book to to own because there's so much good information in it you need
00:53:42.940 to kind of like read a chapter like set it down think about it for a while and then go back to
00:53:46.220 the next chapter because each one is such a interesting story I don't know if you can hear
00:53:50.240 the purring that's my cat Hepburn she's also really psyched she liked talking to Paula
00:53:53.900 Paula has I think uh three cats she said so that recommends a person to me absolutely
00:54:01.580 Anyway, speaking of books that are available to order, I have a book that is coming out
00:54:07.500 next year.
00:54:08.380 It's called Rebel of the Regency, The Scandalous Saga of Carolina Brunswick, Britain's Uncrowned
00:54:12.840 Queen, and it's available now for pre-order.
00:54:16.620 So if you go to rebeloftheregency.com, that's rebeloftheregency.com, you will find information
00:54:23.680 about places where you can pre-order it, although you can just walk to your local neighborhood
00:54:28.220 bookstore or go to their website and order it from them as well. And if you do pre-order my
00:54:34.020 book, you get some special treats or you can opt in to get some special treats. So when you pre-order
00:54:40.120 my book, Rebel of the Regency, go to rebeltheregency.com and you can fill out a little
00:54:44.800 form there to where you upload a picture of your receipt. And then you can say, what are the special
00:54:50.400 treats you want? And the things that I have on offer are you can get one year free paid membership
00:54:55.900 to my Substack newsletter. You can get one year free paid membership to my Patreon. I had thought
00:55:02.600 before though, that wasn't available to current free members, but in fact, it's available to
00:55:06.900 anybody who's not already a paid member for my Patreon. So that's exciting news. And then the
00:55:12.100 other third thing you can get is a Carolina Brunswick digital image that is a Carolina
00:55:18.000 Brunswick paper doll. And when you get the paper doll, you're going to be like, first of all,
00:55:21.740 it's adorable. The paper doll is designed by Siobhan Gallagher, who has done some merch for
00:55:26.340 me before. And it's so cute. Caroline looks so cute. She has outfits you can put on her,
00:55:30.800 accessories and hats. And one of the hats is a hollowed out pumpkin. And you might think, 0.82
00:55:35.360 why is one of the hats on this paper doll a hollowed out pumpkin? And you'll find out when
00:55:38.960 you read my book, Rebel of the Regency. Learn more at rebeloftheregency.com. Anyway, there's
00:55:44.520 also a link in the show notes that if when you're buying Paula's book or my book, if you want to,
00:55:49.060 You could also use my special link to bookshop.org, which is an online service where you can order
00:55:54.620 books from.
00:55:55.780 And when you use my link, then a little bit of money from the book goes towards me.
00:55:59.960 So, and you're not supporting evil billionaire owned businesses by using that store.
00:56:06.620 If you're not sure who to order things from, that link is in the show notes as well.
00:56:10.620 And I think that's everything.
00:56:12.600 so next week well actually actually in two days there's going to be another special bonus episode
00:56:21.000 because it's pride month in north america and there's so many people that i wanted to talk to
00:56:26.500 and share their books and stories with you so that's why we're doubling up a few weeks and
00:56:29.860 this friday is one of those times so we're going to be talking about trans history with some very
00:56:34.660 special guests so stay tuned for that on friday and then otherwise new episodes every week that's
00:56:42.140 what's happening and happy pride. Keep your pants on and your tits out. And I'll talk to you all next 0.99
00:56:49.340 time. Vulgar History is researched, scripted, and hosted by Anne Foster. That's me. Editor is 1.00
00:56:57.360 Christina Lumagi. Theme music is by The Severn Duo. Transcripts of this podcast are available
00:57:02.660 at vulgarhistory.com by Aveline Malek. You can get early ad-free episodes of Vulgar History by
00:57:08.360 becoming a paid member of our Patreon for as low as $1 a month at patreon.com slash Anne Foster 0.59
00:57:14.160 Writer. Vulgar History merchandise is available at vulgarhistory.com slash store for Americans
00:57:19.620 and for everyone else at vulgarhistory.redbubble.com. Follow us on social media at vulgarhistorypod
00:57:26.380 and get in touch with me via email at vulgarhistorypod at gmail.com.
00:57:30.560 Legendary stories, awe-inspiring sound, and endless adventure.
00:57:39.860 Welcome to the Realms of Peril and Glory.
00:57:45.960 Explore the mechanically magical vistas of Vale,
00:57:50.740 the paranormal mysteries of Liminal London,
00:57:54.800 and the cyberpunk chaos of Cyborg.
00:58:02.980 Fall in love with our core cast
00:58:05.760 or be awed by our incredible guests
00:58:08.760 from familiar shows like Oxventure,
00:58:12.080 Three Black Halflings,
00:58:13.760 and No Rolls Barred. 1.00
00:58:17.120 Ignite your imagination
00:58:18.420 and discover the realms of peril and glory today.
00:58:22.360 Go to RealmsPod.com
00:58:24.360 or search Realms of Peril and Glory wherever you listen to podcasts.
00:58:29.760 Two, one, you win!
00:58:32.880 Goodbye, Kyle!
00:58:34.260 Did the sound of those words call to you like Pavlov's dog?
00:58:37.320 Then you might enjoy our podcast, Turtle Time.
00:58:39.980 Every week you can join me, Riley Hamilton, and my co-host, Amy Scarlotta,
00:58:44.380 as we cover the most pressing Bravo news and dig into the new episodes
00:58:48.200 to answer important questions like,
00:58:50.180 who the hell is Adrian Maloof in this world?
00:58:52.340 Listen to Turtle Time on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:58:58.000 New episodes every Wednesday and Friday.
00:59:22.340 no boring takes just the tea new episodes every week if it's trending we're talking about it
00:59:29.440 this is Roxanne and Chantelle let's get into it